EDU 301: Language Across the curriculum
Module 1
1.1. Language – Principles and Functions
Language is a system of
communication used by humans, which is based on a set of symbols, sounds, and
grammar rules. It is the primary means by which we communicate with each other
and share information, thoughts, and emotions. Language enables us to express
our thoughts, ideas, and emotions and to understand the thoughts, ideas, and
emotions of others. It is an essential aspect of human society, culture, and
development. Language can take many forms, including spoken, written, signed,
or gestured, and it allows us to communicate with others in various contexts,
including social, personal, and professional situations.
Language can be defined as a
complex system of communication that uses symbols, sounds, and grammar rules to
convey meaning.
1.1.1. Importance of Language
Language
is of crucial importance for several reasons:
1. Communication: Language is the primary means of
communication between humans. It enables us to convey our thoughts, ideas, and
emotions to others, and to understand the thoughts, ideas, and emotions of
others.
2. Learning: Language is essential for learning and
education. It is the medium through which we acquire knowledge and skills, and
it is necessary for literacy, numeracy, and other forms of academic learning.
3. Socialization: Language is a critical aspect of
socialization. It enables us to form relationships with others, to share
experiences and ideas, and to develop a sense of belonging and identity.
4. Cultural development: Language plays a vital role
in the development of culture and society. It enables us to transmit cultural
values, traditions, and beliefs across generations, and it is essential for the
preservation and development of cultural diversity.
5. Professional success: Language is essential for
professional success in many fields. It is necessary for effective
communication in the workplace, and it can be a valuable asset in fields such
as diplomacy, business, and international relations.
In summary, language is
essential for communication, learning, socialization, cultural development, and
professional success. It is a fundamental aspect of human society and culture,
and its importance cannot be overstated.
1.1.2. Principles of Language
1. Language is a system of symbols
Language is a system of
symbols and it works through symbols, the symbols being words. Language
functions effectively when the symbols used are known to the speaker and
listener, the writer and the reader. The symbolic language is varied and
complex. Language symbols represent things that are not things themselves. The
word "Table' is not a table, it stands for a table. There is no logical
connection between the symbol and the referent. Symbols get their meaning by
convention. There is nothing in their nature which gives them a specific
meaning. Languages use words essentially as symbols and not as signs for the
concepts represented by them.
2. Language is arbitrary
Language is a learned
arbitrary system of vocal symbols by means of which human beings interact and
communicate in terms of their common cultural experiences. There is no
connection between sound and the object it represents, so if people decide
tomorrow to change and modify the sounds, it would be the new acceptable form
of language. Language is changeable with time. So, the teacher should teach
that form of language which is in use.
3. Language is primarily vocal
Language is a system with vocal sounds. It is based on
man's ability and skill to speak. First, most of the time, a man primarily uses
its oral form then goes to written form. Written Language comes at secondary
level in communicating something. Language connects people with each other.
4. Language is for Communication
Language is a medium by which
a person communicates his thoughts, ideas, feelings, expressions, and emotions.
Verbally, we can interpret other's feelings, emotions and ideas also. Language
gives words to emotions. Not only oral and written form is available of
Language but signs, symbols, gestures, animation (of cries laugh, smile, etc.)
are also the part of non-verbal language. The non-verbal and verbal languages
are useful for communication and depend upon each other.
5. Language is a skill
Language is a skill that is
learned by constant practice. Language can be learned not by knowing
about it; but by using it. Just as other skills like swimming, driving,
singing or dancing that are learned by practice, a language is also learned by
constant use. It is acquired first by imitation and then by practice.
6. Language is unique
Every language has its own
unique structure, sounds, and words. No language can be learned resorting the
use of other languages. So, learning of the mother tongue may create a problem.
Mother tongue may be used to facilitate the learning of foreign language but
total dependence will hinder mastery over the target language
7. Language grows out of a culture
Every language has its
validity only in its culture. The words and sounds of a particular culture have
its value, only in its own atmosphere. If the individuals need some change in
the language they can reshape and remodel the language
8. Language grows and changes
Language is not static. It is
dynamic and living as it is dependent upon cultural change. With new words,
sounds and pronunciation a language is enriched and conceives a new form.
1.1.3. Functions of language
Language plays a very
important role in human lives. It is a social phenomenon. One of the main goals
of language is to communicate with people and to understand them. When someone
speaks, he intends a specific purpose. He wants to convey a message through
that language. A person uses his language to many different purposes, for
example, to express his feelings, to ask for help and to apologize.
1. Expressive and Communicative Functions
The most basic function of
language is the expressive function, an attempt to express a sudden change of
state, fear, delight, pain or confusion. Whatever it is, such an expression is
not a deliberate, conscious expression, but a spontaneous, immediate response
not directed towards any other object.
2. Informational Function
The informational function
which everyone tends to assume is most important. In fact, this function
concentrates on the message. It is used to give new information. It depends on
truth and value.
3. Directive Function
The directive function of
language means we use language to influence the behavior or attitudes of
others. The most straightforward instances of the directive function are
commands and requests. Examples of this kind are, I want a cup of tea or close
the door. It is clear to hear that, we use the language in a direct way. We ask
someone to do something. Sometimes we can use a sentence to express two
functions. For example, I am thirsty. The previous example could be used to show
the condition of the speaker or writer or to express the feeling. In a way that
a person asks someone to give him water.
4. Interpretative Functions
Language serves as a function
of becoming aware of interpreting a particular situation. Thus, the cry of one
animal in the face of danger is interpreted by other members of the species.
The interpretative function is very obvious at the human level. The
interpretative function serves to restore a state of cognitive equilibrium.
While the stimulus itself creates a condition of uncertainty or novelty, the
interpretation serves to clarify the situation and restore the equilibrium.
5. Control Function
When one talks of the function of control, there emerges a social dimension apart from the individual dimension. Gradually, as associations get established between certain states of existence and a stimulus on the one hand and certain sounds, there results from reproducibility of a reaction. Thus, the child cries when he is hungry or suffering from pain. This cry, in turn, makes the mother rush and help. Here is the beginning of control. This control function may not be deliberate and conscious, but as one grows and the environment becomes more organized, the control function of language becomes more and more central.
6. The Functions of Remembering and Thinking
Imagine our thinking and
remembering without the use of words. It is almost impossible to recall or
remember or think without the use of words and therefore, language. It si
language, which helps us to encode experiences, store them and retrieve and
decode. It is language, which helps us to translate experiences into thought
and engage in processes of different types.
7. Social Functions of Language
In addition to these individual
functions, language performs a very important social function. While promoting
a sense of personal identity language also serves to develop a sense of social
identity, a sense of belongingness to a particular group, marking out different
degrees of social proximity and distance.
8. Creative Function
Language plays a very crucial
role in imaginative and creative activity. Is it possible to think of writing a
novel or poetry without language? Language then not only helps us to control
and regulate our cognitions but also enables us to break free and engage in
creative imagination.
9. Aesthetic Function
The aesthetic function of
language refers to the use of language for artistic or creative expression.
This includes the use of language in literature, poetry, music, and other forms
of art. The aesthetic function of language allows individuals to appreciate the
beauty and power of language beyond its everyday uses for communication and
practical purposes. It allows language to be used as a form of artistic
expression and to evoke emotions, thoughts, and ideas in the listener or
reader.
10. Phatic Function
The phatic function of language refers to the use of language for establishing and maintaining social relationships and for social interaction. Examples of phatic language use include everyday greetings such as "hello" or "how are you?", small talk about the weather, and social conventions such as saying "please" and "thank you". These language uses do not necessarily convey information or convey it only secondarily; rather, they serve to establish a connection between people and to signal that they are part of the same social group or culture.
1.2 Language and Cognition
Language and cognition are closely intertwined, with
language playing a crucial role in cognitive development and functioning.
Language allows individuals to organize their thoughts and ideas, to
communicate them to others, and to understand and interpret the thoughts and
ideas of others.
Ø
Language
plays a crucial role in cognitive development, as children learn a language,
they also develop their cognitive abilities.
Ø
Language
provides a framework for organizing and processing information in a structured
way.
Ø
Language
affects how individuals perceive and categorize the world around them,
including concepts such as color, time, and causality.
Ø
The
words used to describe an event can affect how individuals perceive and
remember the event later on. This is known as the language-dependent memory
effect.
Ø
Language
allows individuals to communicate their thoughts and ideas to others, and to
understand and interpret the thoughts and ideas of others.
Ø
Different
languages may have different structures and grammar rules that influence how
individuals think and process information.
Ø
Bilingualism
and multilingualism can have positive effects on cognitive functioning,
including enhanced executive functioning and improved memory.
Language and cognition are closely intertwined and
influence each other in complex ways. It is generally accepted that mother
tongue is the natural language of thought for the child and eminently suited
for concept formation. Mother tongue is the only tool for logical thoughts and
expressions while any language may be the language of added comprehension. The
language with which one lives and grows is best suited to achieving originality
in thoughts.
Language is more than communication skills and language are linked to the cognitive process. It is a tool for conceptualizing and for linking information. The language supports mental activities and precision in cognition. It helps to bridge between cognitively demanding tasks and their solutions and also to structure consolidations or discourse. Availability of language symbols makes human thinking more sophisticated than the thinking of other animals.
1.2.1. Role of Language in Cognitive development and
learning needs of children
The role of language in
cognitive development and learning needs of children is significant. Here are
some key points:
1. Language plays a crucial role in cognitive
development: Language
and cognition are intertwined, and language acquisition is an important part of
cognitive development in children. Language allows children to organize their
thoughts and ideas, and it helps them develop cognitive abilities such as
attention, memory, and problem-solving skills.
2. Language helps children learn: Language is essential for learning, as it allows
children to communicate with others, understand instructions, and acquire knowledge.
Language is also critical for literacy development, which is a fundamental part
of learning.
3. Language development varies by age and stage: Children's language development varies by age and
stage, with infants and toddlers developing basic language skills, such as
vocabulary and grammar, and older children developing more advanced language
skills, such as narrative and abstract thinking.
4. Language development is influenced by environment: Children's language development is influenced by their
environment, including their family, community, and cultural context. Children
who grow up in language-rich environments are more likely to develop strong
language skills.
5. Language plays a role in social-emotional
development: Language is
not only essential for cognitive development but also for social-emotional
development. Language allows children to express their feelings and needs,
understand the feelings of others, and build relationships.
6. Children with language delays require support: Children with language delays or disorders require
support to develop their language skills. Early intervention and therapy can
help these children catch up with their peers and improve their cognitive and
learning outcomes.
Famous psychologist Vygotsky
identified that there are three different stages in the children's use of
language. Firstly, language is an essential factor for communication
(social speech). Next, children begin to use egocentric or private
speech to control their own thinking. The last stage is language
development. Children use verbal thoughts to guide what they are thinking and
their actions. Language and thought first become independent after them being
interdependent. Attainment of a new word was the beginning of the development
of a concept.
During early childhood,
children's abilities to understand, to process, and to produce language also
flourish in an amazing way. Young children experience a language explosion
between the ages of 3 and 6. At age 3, their spoken vocabularies consist of
roughly 900 words. By age 6, spoken vocabularies expand dramatically to
anywhere between 8,000 and 14,000 words. During infancy and toddlerhood,
young children are almost always able to understand far many more words than
they can speak. However, with this language explosion, their expressive (spoken
language) abilities start to catch up with their receptive (ability to
comprehend language) skills.
As children move beyond using
two-word sentences, they start to learn and understand grammar rules. Beyond
growing their vocabularies, young children start to expand their ability to use
different forms of words and form more complex sentences. School-age children
start to speak more like adults; they can recognize basic grammar errors, put
thoughts into question form, and begin including negative expressions such as
"not coming" into their sentences. As they get older, children's use
of language also becomes more mature and complicated as a result of their
cognitive development. The following are the different modes of human
activities involving language:
·
Listening:
comprehending oral input/intake
·
Speaking:
constructing meaningful utterances
·
Reading:
understanding written texts
·
Writing:
producing written texts/discourse
·
Viewing:
attending to visual signs/information
·
Shaping:
using visual means of expression
·
Watching:
attending to the movements
·
Moving:
using the whole body / person
In summary, language is
crucial for cognitive development and learning needs of children. Language
allows children to organize their thoughts, communicate with others, acquire
knowledge, and develop social-emotional skills. Children's language development
varies by age and stage, and it is influenced by their environment. Children
with language delays or disorders require support to develop their language
skills and reach their full potential.
MODULE 2
LANGUAGE DIVERSITY
IN THE CLASSROOM
2.1. Multilingualism: Meaning, Nature and Scope
Multilingualism
refers to the ability of an individual or a society to use and understand
multiple languages. An individual who uses more than two languages with equal
proficiency is called multilingual (Polyglot). Multilingualism can manifest in
various ways, including bilingualism (the ability to use two languages),
trilingualism (the ability to use three languages), and even more complex
language abilities.
There are many benefits to
multilingualism, both for individuals and for society as a whole.
For individuals, being
able to speak multiple languages can improve cognitive abilities, such
as problem-solving and memory retention. It can also enhance job
opportunities, particularly in today's globalized economy, and improve
cultural understanding and communication with people from different
backgrounds. And also
·
Exhibit
superior linguistic knowledge.
·
Develop
a greater vocabulary.
·
Parcel
up and categorize meanings in different ways.
·
Develop not only better verbal but also
spatial abilities.
·
Learn
further languages more quickly and efficiently.
·
Be
better problem solvers by gaining multiple perspectives on issues at hand.
·
Have
improved critical thinking abilities.
·
See
their own culture from a new perspective not available to monoglots, enabling
the comparison, contrast, and understanding of cultural concepts.
For society,
multilingualism can foster greater tolerance and understanding between
different cultures, and it can help to preserve endangered languages and
cultural heritage. In addition, it can provide economic benefits by facilitating
trade and business relationships with other countries.
Nature and Scope of Multilingualism
1. Multilingualism is the ability of an individual or
a community to use and understand multiple languages.
2. The nature of multilingualism can vary depending on
the context. For example, some individuals may grow up in a household where
multiple languages are spoken, while others may learn additional languages
through formal education or immersion programs.
3. The way in which languages are used can also vary,
with some individuals being fully proficient in multiple languages and others
being more proficient in one language over the others.
4. Multilingualism can enhance cognitive abilities,
such as problem-solving and memory retention.
5. Multilingualism can also improve job opportunities,
particularly in today's globalized economy, and improve cultural understanding
and communication with people from different backgrounds.
6. Multilingualism can foster greater tolerance and
understanding between different cultures, and it can help to preserve
endangered languages and cultural heritage.
7. The scope of multilingualism can vary depending on
the context, with some communities or societies being predominantly monolingual
and others being highly multilingual.
8. The scope of multilingualism can also refer to the
domains in which languages are used, such as education, government, or
business.
9. Understanding the nature of multilingualism is
important for promoting linguistic diversity and developing policies and
programs that support multilingual individuals and communities.
2.1.2. Deficit Theory (Rebecca. G. Eller-1989)
The deficit theory by Eller
claims that children from disadvantaged populations are intellectually
disadvantaged as a result of inferior linguistic development. Working-class
children have an inadequate command of grammar and vocabulary to express
complex ideas. Deficit theory explains why students fail in using a second
language. They have the poor linguistic ability, weak vocabulary foundation,
limited range of grammatical constructions, and inadequate communicative
ability with persons from a different language background, lack of coherence in
their presentations. As a result, students experience psychological problems
and feel incompetent in class.
Deficit theory also suggests
that teachers avoid labelling children as verbally inept when their language
doesn't conform to the teacher's linguistic model. A teacher in a multilingual
set-up can:
·
Develop
learner's level of confidence through rewards and reinforcement.
·
Build
their self-esteem. Give them simpler tasks.
·
Provide
a collaborative learning environment.
·
Help them to develop their vocabulary.
Eller's deficit theory has
been criticized by some educators and researchers for placing blame on students
and their families for their perceived cultural deficiencies, rather than
addressing broader societal factors that contribute to educational inequality.
However, others argue that the theory is useful in helping educators to
understand the challenges that students from marginalized backgrounds face, and
to develop more effective strategies for supporting their academic success.
2.3 Discontinuity Theory
Noam Chomsky's discontinuity
theory, also known as the nativist theory of language acquisition, argues that
the ability to learn language is innate and biologically determined. According
to this theory, children are born with a language acquisition device (LAD), a
cognitive mechanism that allows them to learn and understand language rapidly
and without explicit instruction.
Discontinuity theory explains
that students experience a discontinuity in learning or functioning due to
several factors that adversely affect their self-esteem (failure, deficits,
etc.). It assumes that some kind of experienced discontinuities directly challenges
personal esteem, of children. In a multilingual set-up, this problem can create
a low academic achievement, psychological distress, and maladjustment in the
classroom.
Differences in the functional
use of language among culturally and linguistically diverse children have been
found to account for the discontinuity they experience in the school. The
discourse structure and communication styles used by children from culturally
and linguistically diverse populations is in harmonious with that of the teacher's
style of interaction.
The difference in home language and school language
(formal) creates maladjustment in children. This discontinuity between home and
school language socialization patterns can have a negative impact on academic
achievement.
A teacher in a multilingual
classroom can have a great role in minimizing discontinuity. She/he can use the
following ways.
·
Familiarize
oneself with cultural diversity in classrooms.
·
Create
a culturally inclusive learning environment.
·
Timely
intervention to check the classroom behavior of all students.
·
Narrow
the disconnection between home and school by understanding learner's
background.
·
Include
community support resources.
2.4 Sociocultural Variants with special focus to
Dialect and Register
Sociocultural variants are
linguistic features or patterns that are associated with particular social or
cultural groups, and reflect the influence of social and cultural factors on
language use. These variants can include differences in pronunciation, grammar,
vocabulary, and discourse style, and can be influenced by factors such as
social class, ethnicity, gender, age, region, and education. Some examples of
sociocultural variants in language include:
1. Pronunciation differences: Some sociocultural groups may have distinct
pronunciation patterns that are associated with their regional or ethnic
identity. For example, speakers of African American English may use a different
pronunciation of certain vowels and consonants than speakers of Standard
American English.
2. Vocabulary differences: Sociocultural groups may also use different words or
phrases to describe the same concepts or experiences. For example, speakers of
British English may use different vocabulary for certain foods, clothing, or
transportation than speakers of American English.
3. Grammatical differences: Different sociocultural groups may also use
different grammar patterns or structures. For example, speakers of Spanish may
use different verb tenses or pronoun forms than speakers of English.
4. Discourse style differences: Sociocultural groups may have different patterns of
discourse, such as the use of storytelling or humor, or the use of indirect or
direct communication styles. For example, some cultures may value indirect
communication and avoid direct confrontation or criticism.
Overall, sociocultural
variants reflect the complex interplay between language and culture, and
highlight the importance of understanding the social and cultural context of
language use.
Dialect and register are two important concepts in linguistics that refer
to different aspects of language variation and usage.
Dialect refers to the variation of language that occurs
within a language community or across different language communities. Dialects can
vary in terms of pronunciation, vocabulary, grammar, and other linguistic
features, and can be influenced by factors such as geography, social class,
ethnicity, and historical events. Dialects are classified as social dialects
and regional dialects. The language of medical doctors, legal officers,
laboratory physicists, literary critics, etc. are the examples of social
dialects. A single word can be used in different areas in different ways for
eg. Friend- gudy, machan, annan, aliyan etc. are the examples of
regional dialects.
Register, on the other hand, refers to the level of formality
or informality of language used in a particular context. Different registers
can be used in different situations or settings, such as in formal or informal writing,
academic or casual conversation, or professional or personal communication.
Register can be influenced by factors such as social context, audience,
purpose, and genre. For example, the language used in a legal document
will be more formal and technical than the language used in a personal letter.
The different types of registers are formal, informal, technical,
poetic, frozen (static), and intimate register
While dialect and register are
distinct concepts, they can also intersect and influence each other. For
example, speakers of a particular dialect may use different registers in
different contexts, such as using a more formal register in a job interview
than when talking with friends.
2.3. Understanding the Language background of the
students
We can understand the
different cultures of a student as a language reflects one's culture. It
fosters improved understanding between learners and develops cultural pluralism
and openness to and appreciation of other cultures. The linguistic diversity of
the nation demands an understanding of linguistic variations etc. The
linguistic and cultural diversity of India and the multicultural background of the
students demands the need for understanding the linguistic background of the
learner. Learners' language background is one of the factors which may
influence the amount and functions of own-language use in academic language
instruction.
2.3.1. Home language vs. School language
Home language basically refers
to the language we use at home and outside of school to converse with our
family members, friends, relatives, etc. In simple terms, it's our mother
tongue. Home language is that which we use to directly express what we feel,
think or want, without any complications.
On the other hand, school language
may refer to the language/medium of instruction used by the teacher to teach
and made compulsory for students to speak. This language is not necessarily
used by students outside the school premises. School language tends to be a
model for what one can use later on in life in formal situations (an interview,
a meeting, so on and so forth).
Interference of home language
with school language is seen in three realms. It has a negative impact in the
understanding of sounds and in pronouncing words in the school language, in
understanding and using structural variations, in learning the grammar of the language,
and in learning the vocabulary/confusion at the phonetic, structural and
lexical levels may occur.
2.3.2. First and Second language Learners
The first language is
'acquired' and the second language is learned'. The difference between these
two words describes the qualities of the two languages. A first language is the
mother tongue or native language of a person while a second language is a language
a person learns in order to communicate with the native speaker of that
language.
The first language is like an
instinct which is triggered by birth and developed with the experience of being
exposed to it. A second language is a personal choice of a person. There is no
other alternative to a first language. A person cannot decide his/her first
language. It comes to him/her as an inheritance. On the other hand, a second
language is always fixed by the person. There are many alternatives to a second
language. A person/community can choose a second language among other
languages. The acquiring process of the first language is very rapid while the
learning process of the second language can vary from language to language and
from person to person, but can never be as rapid as the first language
acquisition.
The following are the factors
of difference for the first language and the second language learners.
1. Age: It is the most important factor that makes a second language totally
different from the first language. Children of the age of6 who have already acquired
full proficiency in their first language is most capable of learning a second
language. Adults usually find it difficult to learn a new language when they
become too accustomed to their first/native language.
2. Personality: A child's personality does not usually make that much
of difference in the acquisition of the first language. But it makes a huge
difference in the learning process of the second language. In the second
language learning process, the learners with an introvert personality usually
make slow progress than the learners with an extrovert personality
3. Culture: The first language is one of the most important
factors of a person's culture. But a second language is not that important in
anyone's culture. However, the second language has some effects on the culture
of a person but not significant enough to be counted as an element of that
culture.
4. Motivation: It is an important factor for second language
learning. A learner with good motivation to learn a second language is likely to
learn that language faster. But the acquisition of the first language does not require
any motivation because it is a natural phenomenon. The first language is
acquired subconsciously and there is no need for motivation to acquire it.
5. Mother Tongue: The first language is the mother tongue of a person.
The second language learning depends a lot on the structures of the first
language. If the structure of the first language is similar to the second
language, it will be easy and fast for the learners to internalize it. For
instance, an English native speaker will find Dutch easier to learn than Hindi
as a second language.
A first language and a second
language both have their effects on each other. However. as we have learned
that the first language is natural and has a solid base in a person's
intellectual and psychological development, the first language is not affected
by the second language as much as the second language is affected by the first
language.
2.3.3. Language used in teaching the subject - issues
and Challenges
Two distinct types of language
acquisition include (a) BICS: Basic Interpersonal Communicative Skills
and (b) CALP: Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency.
Basic Interpersonal
Communicative Skills
encompass the social language that we use on a regular basis - to make plans
with friends, to talk about our daily activities, etc. It is usually the first
step in acquiring another language. However, the language that is needed for
academic success is different. Academic language requires more technical
vocabulary, more sophisticated sentence structure, and a nuanced understanding
of how language is used within academic disciplines. It takes much longer to
develop the Cognitive Academic Language Proficiency that will enable students
to succeed in higher level studies
Cognitive Academic Language
Proficiency in the
disciplines requires knowledge of precise, sometimes technical language as well
as familiarity with notations and symbols that may vary from one culture to
another. Language word problems commonly contain more advanced grammatical
structures, such as indirect speech and the passive voice. Linking words within
sentences and transitional words or phrases among sentences carry important
meaning that may not catch the attention of non-native speakers of English.
Academic language is the
language needed by students to do the work in schools. It includes, for
example, discipline-specific vocabulary, grammar and punctuation, and
applications of rhetorical conventions and devices that are typical for a
content area (e.g., essays, lab reports, discussions of a controversial issue.)
One of the goals for the learning segment should be to further develop
students' academic language abilities. This means that our learning objectives
should focus on language as well as on content. Some of the challenges are
listed below:
• Creating shared objectives
for language development in higher education
• Allocating sufficient
resources to language development
• Implementing a post-entry
language assessment
• Ensuring students take up
language development opportunities.
The language used in teaching
a subject can have significant implications for learning outcomes and student
engagement. Some of the issues and challenges associated with language use in
teaching include:
1. Language proficiency: Teachers need to have a high level of proficiency in
the language they are teaching in order to effectively communicate complex
concepts and engage students in meaningful discussions. If a teacher's language
skills are not up to par, it can lead to misunderstandings, confusion, and
disengagement among students.
2. Language diversity: In many educational contexts, students come from
diverse linguistic backgrounds and may not have the same level of proficiency
in the language of instruction. Teachers need to be sensitive to these
differences and provide support and accommodations to help all students
succeed.
3. Cultural relevance: The language used in teaching should be culturally
relevant and appropriate for the students' background and experiences. If the
language is overly formal, technical, or unfamiliar, it can create a sense of
disconnection or alienation among students.
4. Language barriers: Language barriers can be a major obstacle to
effective teaching and learning. Teachers need to be aware of the linguistic
needs and abilities of their students and use strategies such as visual aids,
gestures, and simplified language to facilitate communication and
understanding.
5. Bilingual education: In some educational contexts, bilingual education is
used to help students learn subject matter in their native language and
gradually transition to the language of instruction. This approach can help to
bridge the gap between different linguistic and cultural backgrounds and promote
more equitable learning outcomes.
Overall, the language used in teaching a subject is a complex and multifaceted issue that requires careful consideration and attention to the needs of both teachers and students. By being aware of these challenges and using effective language teaching strategies, teachers can create a more engaging, supportive, and effective learning environment for all students.
MODULE 3
LANGUAGE ACROSS
THE CURRICULUM: CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS
3.1 LAC Concept
Language
across curriculum is a concept that refers to the integration of language
learning into all subject areas of the curriculum. This approach recognizes
that language is not just a subject to be taught in isolation but a tool for
learning, communication, and understanding. Language across curriculum aims to
promote language proficiency, critical thinking, and subject area knowledge
simultaneously. In this essay, we will explore the concept of language across
curriculum, its benefits, and challenges.
The concept of language across
curriculum recognizes that language is the medium through which students learn
and communicate about various subject areas. It emphasizes the use of language
as a tool for critical thinking, comprehension, and expression. This approach
is based on the belief that students learn best when they can use language to
engage with subject matter, rather than simply memorizing and regurgitating
information.
In language across curriculum,
teachers incorporate language learning strategies into their subject-specific
lessons to help students develop a deeper understanding of subject matter. For
example, a science teacher might use language activities to teach scientific
vocabulary and concepts, while an English teacher might use literary analysis to
teach students how to read and interpret complex texts.
The benefits of
language across curriculum are numerous. First, it promotes a deeper
understanding of subject matter. By incorporating language learning strategies
into subject-specific lessons, students can engage with material at a deeper
level, leading to a more profound understanding of the content.
Second, language across curriculum promotes language
proficiency. By using language learning strategies in different subject areas,
students can develop their language skills in a variety of contexts. This leads
to improved language proficiency and a greater ability to communicate
effectively in different settings.
Third, language across curriculum promotes critical
thinking. By using language to engage with subject matter, students can develop
their analytical and critical thinking skills. This leads to a greater ability
to analyze complex information and draw conclusions based on evidence.
However, implementing language
across curriculum can also present challenges. First, teachers need to
be trained in language learning strategies and be able to incorporate them into
subject-specific lessons. This requires a significant investment of time and
resources.
Second, language across curriculum can be challenging for
students who are not proficient in the language of instruction. Teachers need
to be aware of the language needs of their students and provide appropriate
support to ensure that all students can participate in class activities.
In conclusion, language across
curriculum is a powerful approach to teaching that recognizes the integral role
of language in learning and understanding subject matter. By promoting language
proficiency, critical thinking, and subject area knowledge simultaneously,
language across curriculum offers numerous benefits to students. However,
implementing this approach can present challenges that need to be addressed
through teacher training and support for language learners.
LAC emphasizes that language
development is the responsibility of all teachers across the school and in all
subject areas as each subject area has its own specific language usage, style,
specialized vocabulary and different writing genres. Language teachers
introduce and teach language skills, reinforcing them from time to time in
language lessons. Content subject teachers re-teach those skills or introduce
related skills/concepts in their lesson, integrating language and content. For example,
the idea of suffixes has been introduced in English lessons. The History
teacher can introduce the new suffix -ism' and give examples such as
'communism' or 'colonialism', or consolidate familiar suffixes, like 'ion' in
'rebellion'.
3.2 Origins of the LAC
Language Across the Curriculum
as a concept developed in the late 70s and early 80s of the last centuries. It
originated in Great Britain, where the idea of linking LAC with school language
policies as a whole received formal recognition after it was mentioned in
Bullock Report (entitled A Language for Life):
"Each school should have
an organized language policy for language across the curriculum, establishing
every teacher's involvement in language and reading development throughout the
years of schooling".
Chapter 12 of the Bullock Report (1975) emphasized
three essential elements:
.1 Language crosses the
curriculum
2. Every teacher is therefore by
definition a language teacher
3. Every school should have a (whole)
language policy.
The Bullock Report looked
mainly at language in the context of the mother tongue. However, in many cases,
the conclusions can be applied to the foreign language context, in particular
the notion that language crosses the curriculum. A decade later this was
underlined in the Swann Report (Education for Al):
"Unless there is a school
language and learning policy across the curriculum there will be wastage of effort
and often confusion".
The ideas of LAC itself, which
had received real impetus in that report, have somewhat changed over time, they
were also influenced by work outside Britain.
3.3 Basic Tenets of LAC
The basic tenets on which LAC
rests focus on the importance of language in and for school education, for all
subject- matter learning, across the whole curriculum.
·
Language
develops mainly through its purposeful use (domains to be broadened).
·
Learning
often involves talking, writing, shaping and moving (in reaction to
perceptions).
·
Learning
often occurs more through talking and writing as much as through shaping and
moving
·
Language
use contributes to or is a pre-requisite for cognitive development
·
Language
is the medium for reflecting learning, for improving it for becoming
autonomous.
3.4 Need and Scope
The language is always
believed to play a central role in learning. No matter what the subject area,
students assimilate new concepts when they listen, talk, read and write about
what they are learning. As such, language acts as a vehicle for educational
development and is important for the apprehension and acquisition of knowledge.
In the educational context Language Across the curriculum:
·
Provides
opportunities for better comprehension and making use of knowledge.
·
Supports
language development in all domains and each activity of the school.
·
Supports
meaningful learning.
·
Provides
the same kind of educational experience for all with regard to the learning of
languages.
·
Develops
multilingualism by becoming culturally sensitive and knowledgeable.
·
Helps
schools to mentor confident language users.
·
Develops
autonomous learners capable of linking language with their learning.
·
Allows
all teachers to work towards a common goal.
·
Provides
cognitively engaging contexts for language practice and integrates language
development with content learning.
3.5 Advantages and Limitations of Language Across the
Curriculum
As Language Across Curriculum
offers a more realistic and functional learning of foreign language, it helps
students become effective user of the language in day today communication as
well as in academic and professional aspects of communication. Adopting the
concept of Language Across the Curriculum would:
·
Enable
teachers to contribute and get support in dealing with language in learning
issues as well as to work for a common target.
·
Use
the language to teach more effectively and help students learn more
effectively.
·
Help
the students to minimize the problems of adjusting to the new medium of
instruction and to learn the subject content better.
·
Help
schools to mentor confident language users.
·
Develop
autonomous learners capable of linking language with their learning.
·
Provide
same kind of educational experience for all with regard to learning of
languages.
·
Help
develop plurilingualism or multilingualism by assisting learners of different
languages to become linguistically and culturally sensitive and knowledgeable.
·
Facilitates
a more flexible and authentic foreign language acquisition.
It also provides many other
benefits including greater academic achievement, greater cognitive development
and more positive attitude towards other languages and cultures. Besides these
advantages there are some limitations too.
·
It
is important for language teachers and content subject teachers to each know
what the other is doing. For instance, the English teacher can teach students
how to do a vocabulary log. The content subject teachers then ask students to
keep a vocabulary log for their own subject.
·
As
every subject has to contribute to the language development of students, a balance
between an emphasis on language and an emphasis on content is recommended.
·
Since
more time and effort has to be spent on the development of students' language
proficiency, the subject content may have to be reduced, especially at the
initial stages.
MODULE 4
MODELS OF LANGUAGE
ACROSS THE CURRICULUM
4.1 Content and Language Integrated Learning (CLIL)
Content and Language
Integrated Learning is a term created in 1994 by David Marsh and Anne Maljers
as a curriculum innovation in Finland. It is an approach for learning content
through an additional language (foreign or second), thus teaching both the
subject and the language.
Content and Language
Integrated Learning refers ot any dual-focused educational context in which an additional
language, thus not usually the first language of the learners involved, is used
as a medium in the teaching and learning of non- language content. It is
dual-focused because whereas attention may be predominantly on either
subject-specific content or language, both are always accommodated. It enables
the non-native speakers of English to communicate in the target language. They communicate
what their education has enabled them to discover. They also communicate what
this planet earth has revealed to them. It refers to situations where subjects,
or part of subjects, are taught through a foreign language, or parts of
subjects, are taught through a second language with dual focused aims, namely
the learning of content and the simultaneous learning of a foreign language.
The 'content' in CLIL is the
non-language subjects such as science, mathematics, history, arts etc. The
'language' in CLIL is the language of learning, the language for learning and
the language through learning. Learning acts as a mediating tool through which
content and language are co-constructed.
The primary aim of a teacher
of CLIL is to ensure that within a given space and time, there is progress in
learning of a second language as well as the learning of content introduced in
the class. The objectives may vary from class to class in order to fulfil the
intended aim of the CLIL teacher. It is therefore understood that the role of
the teacher in this regard is two-pronged- to achieve the objective of learning
content, and use the target language. In the event of integrating language and
content by the teacher, it is understood that the content for language learning
will serve the stated dual purpose of learning of language was using authentic.
While learning language and content simultaneously, the students' metacognitive
ability is enabled, thus, commanding a degree of control over the pace and
depth of one's learning. The level of motivation is raised to learn a second
language through specific content.
Challenges
·
Understanding
how content can be integrated into a multilingual context
·
To
diversify the content for students of different language backgrounds
·
To
make the language of the content the language of the class especially if
diverse language learners are present in class
·
Need
for multiple foci
·
To
develop creative and constructive language and content learning environment
·
To
make learning authentic, real and natural for the students
·
Adequate
resources or support structures and co-operation from teachers
·
Need
for competent educators
Educational implications
v
CLIL
introduce the wider cultural context
v
Prepare
for internationalization
v
Access
International Certification and enhance the school profile
v
Improve
overall and specific language competence, prepare for future studies and
working life
v
Develop
multilingual interests and attitudes
v
Diversify
methods and forms of classroom teaching and learning
v
Increase
learner motivation
4.2 Bilingual Teaching
Bilingual teaching is defined
as the teaching of academic content in two languages, in a native and secondary
language with varying amounts of each language used in accordance with the
need. The primary goal of bilingual teaching is not necessarily to teach native
or a second language, but to teach children concepts, knowledge and skills
through the language they know best and reinforce this information through the
second language. Bilingual teaching necessitates rethinking the entire curriculum
in terms of a child's best instruments for learning, of his/her readiness for
learning various subjects, and his/her own identity and potential for growth
and development.
Advantages
Ø The mastery of foreign language is deepened as it
provides support for learners to engage in conversations and actively use the
academic language of their subject.
Ø The understanding of words and sentences in foreign languages
can be made easier by the use of mother tongue.
Ø There is no need to create artificial situations for
explaining the meaning of words and sentences of the target language.
Ø The teacher can save time as the mother tongue is
used.
Ø It sustains student interest.
Ø This method is less costly as the use of teaching aids
is minimum.
Ø It is less strenuous for teachers.
Disadvantages
§
It
cannot be applied in multi linguistic group.
§
It
requires teachers well versed ni both languages.
§
Frequent
comparison and contrast with mother tongue may cause confusion.
§
This
method diverges the attention of students.
§
It
spoils the continuity and fluency of the language.
§
It
can lead to defective pronunciation.
§
It
reduces student's exposure to the target language.
4.3 Language for Specific Purposes (LSP)
Language for Specific Purposes
(LSP) refers to the use of a particular language to meet the specific
communicative needs of a particular group of people in a specific context or
field. The aim of LSP is to provide learners with the language skills and
knowledge needed to effectively communicate in a specific professional or
academic setting.
LSP is often used in language
teaching and learning, where it is important for students to have a command of
the language that is appropriate for their professional or academic goals. For
example, LSP might be used in teaching English to students who plan to work in
a specific industry, such as healthcare, engineering, or law. In such cases,
the language and vocabulary used in the course would be tailored to the needs
of the industry.
LSP courses typically focus on
the specific vocabulary, grammar, and communication skills needed for a
particular profession or field. They may also include specialized materials,
such as technical manuals, scientific articles, or legal documents, which
students are expected to read and understand in the target language.
Overall, LSP is an important
approach to language learning that helps students develop the skills they need
to communicate effectively in specific professional or academic settings.
Features of LSP
ü Learner-centered
ü Second/foreign language training
ü Needs-based
ü Involving stakeholders
ü Characterized by collaboration with workplace/content experts
ü Meets the specific needs of the learners
ü Work specific
4.4 Academic Language Teaching (ALT)
Academic language refers to
the oral, written, auditory, and visual language proficiency required to learn
effectively in schools and academic programs. It is the language of school and
it is used in textbooks, essays, assignments, class presentations and
assessments. It is the language that students are expected to learn and achieve
fluency in. Academic language is used at all grade levels, although its frequency
increases as students get older. It is the language needed by students to
understand words in context and to use language that can convey ideas clearly
without causing any confusion in the listener's mind. In other words, Academic
language is the language used by teachers to impart new information and to
describe ideas clearly so as to increase student understanding. It is more refined
than the usual conversational style.
Academic language teaching is
the ability to relate events in a convincing and accurate manner, make
comparisons in a clear manner, make judgements based on textual evidences, have
good knowledge of the different forms of words and use content-specific
vocabulary and modes of expression needed in that content area. The teaching of
the Academic Language component, (vocabulary, grammar, syntax, style, etc.) is
complex and requires a deep understanding of the language demands of the
content. For example, challenging language demands in math include: symbolic
notation; visual displays, such as charts and graphs; technical vocabulary: and
grammatical features such as complex noun phrases.
MODULE 5
OPERATOI NALISING LANGUAGE ACROSS CURRICULUM IN
CLASSROOM
5.1 Academic language across Subjects
Academic language is the oral
and written language used for academic purposes. It is the "language of
the discipline" used to engage students in learning and includes the means
by which students develop and express content understandings. Academic Language
is believed to be one of the most important factors in the academic success. It
is the language needed by students to do the work in schools. It includes, for
example, discipline-specific vocabulary, grammar and punctuation, and
applications of rhetorical conventions and devices that are typical for a
content area (e.g., essays, lab reports, discussions of a controversial issue).
In school, students use language to make sense of the world that surrounds them,
and, in the process, they are (1) learning language, (2) learning through
language, and (3) learning about language.
The register of academic
language generally includes features that are used across all academic subjects;
each particular subject then has additional features of its own. Features can
include pronunciation, intonation, words chosen or not chosen, particular
meanings of words, preferred sentence structures, accepted discourse patterns,
common ways of accomplishing functions of language, and pragmatic rules.
Components: components of academic language are as follows:
1. Vocabulary: Academic language requires a range of vocabulary,
including discipline-specific terms, technical jargon, and words with precise
meanings. It also requires knowledge of academic vocabulary such as transition
words and phrases.
2. Grammatical structures: Academic language uses complex sentence structures
with multiple clauses and a variety of conjunctions and linking words. It also
uses a range of tenses, voice, and mood to convey precise meanings.
3. Functions: Academic language serves specific functions such as
describing, analyzing, comparing, contrasting, explaining, and synthesizing
information. The language is used to make arguments, present evidence, and
support claims.
4.Text structures: Academic language follows specific text structures
depending on the genre of the text. For example, an argumentative essay will
have an introduction, body paragraphs, and a conclusion. A lab report will have
a methodology section, results section, and a discussion section.
In addition to the components
listed above, academic language also requires critical thinking skills,
cultural knowledge, and the ability to use appropriate register and tone. It is
important to note that the components of academic language may vary depending
on the discipline or subject area.
5.2 Informational Reading and Writing across Subjects
Reading is the complex
cognitive process of decoding symbols ot derive meaning. It si a form of
language processing. Success in this process is measured as reading
comprehension. Reading is a means for language acquisition, communication, and
sharing information and ideas. General purposes of reading are reading for
pleasure, to find general information, to skim for general information, to integrate
information and critique texts, etc.
Informational reading is to
inform readers about something which are not fictional in nature. Examples of
informational texts include a table of contents, an index, bold or italicized
text, glossaries for specialized vocabulary, embedded definitions for §
specialized vocabulary, realistic illustrations of photos, captions, and other
labels, and graphs and charts, question and answer books, reference books, etc.
When you read a National Geographic article about the polar ice caps melting,
or scan a local news feature about the rise in unemployment rates, you're
reading informational writing.
Informational writing is a
type of nonfiction writing that conveys information about something, which
means it is factual. Many examples of informational writing can be found in
newspapers, almanacs, and reference books. Informational text is often
organized so the reader can easily and quickly find information. Informative
writing educates readers by imparting straightforward information and facts,
but never personal opinions.
5.3 Nature of Classroom discourse
Discourses and Class room discourses
Discourses are written or
spoken communication.
It is a formal, orderly and usually extended expression of thought on a subject
and the contextual needs.
Classroom discourses are a linguistic unit (such as a conversation or a story)
larger than a sentence. Classroom discourse is an essential component in
teaching and in building a classroom community. It is the language that
teachers and students use to communicate with each other in the classroom.
Talking or conversation is the medium through which most teaching takes place.
The ability to use oral language to communicate effectively is a key
foundation for academic success as well as social and economic participation
across the life span. The ability to use language effectively impacts on children's
learning, their social behavior in and out of the classroom and their ability
to develop literacy and numeracy skills. It not only improves their basic
conversational skills but also instils them with the tools needed to understand
and talk about academic topics in the target language.
Classroom discourses are chiefly academic discourses that emphasize
expression of a language either through the oral or written modes. Oral
discourse is just as it sounds. It is communication or transfer of
information using words that are spoken. It includes congratulating, ordering,
demanding, promising, hinting, warning, or greeting etc. Written discourse
is also the transfer of information, but, as its name suggests, it involves the
written word. Examples of written discourse are essay, paragraph, article,
short notes, reports, story, diary entry, poster, letter, summary etc.
Nature of Classroom discourse refers to the way in which teachers and students
interact through language in the classroom. The nature of classroom
discourse is influenced by a variety of factors, such as the teacher's teaching
style, the students' learning style, the subject matter being taught, the age
and culture of the students, and the physical environment of the classroom.
Effective classroom discourse
should aim to promote learning and create a positive learning environment. It
should encourage students to actively participate, express their thoughts and
ideas, and engage in critical thinking. Classroom discourse should also be
inclusive, respectful, and promote equality and diversity. Teachers can achieve
this by using strategies such as asking open-ended questions, promoting
dialogue and discussion, encouraging active listening, providing feedback, and
using various modes of communication, such as verbal and nonverbal cues.
However, the nature of
classroom discourse can also be impacted by negative factors such as classroom
management issues, lack of engagement from students, language barriers, and
power imbalances. Teachers must be aware of these factors and take steps to
mitigate them in order to ensure that classroom discourse remains positive and
effective.
The nature of classroom
discourse encompasses a variety of aspects, including oral language, discussion
as a tool for learning, and the nature of questioning in the classroom.
1. Oral language plays
a significant role in classroom discourse, as it is the primary means of
communication between teachers and students. Effective classroom discourse
involves the use of clear, concise language that is appropriate for the
students' age and language proficiency level. Teachers should also model good
oral language skills, such as proper pronunciation, intonation, and pacing.
2. Discussion is
another important tool for learning in the classroom. It encourages students to
express their thoughts and ideas, engage in critical thinking, and learn from
each other. Discussions can take many forms, such as small group discussions,
whole-class discussions, or debates. Teachers should facilitate these
discussions by providing clear prompts and guidelines, encouraging active
listening, and asking open-ended questions that promote deeper thinking.
3. The nature of
questioning in the classroom is also an important aspect of classroom
discourse. Effective questioning can help students clarify their understanding,
make connections, and engage in higher-order thinking. Teachers should use a
variety of questioning techniques, such as asking open-ended questions, using
wait time, and using probing questions to encourage students to elaborate on
their responses. It is also important for teachers to provide feedback on
student responses and to create a supportive environment where students feel
comfortable sharing their thoughts and ideas.
There are several types of
questions that teachers may ask in the classroom. These include:
1. Open-ended questions: These are questions that require more than a
one-word answer and often elicit a range of responses from students. For
example, "What do you think is the main message of this story?"
2. Closed-ended questions: These are questions that can be answered with a
simple yes or no or a short phrase. For example, "Did you understand the
math problem?"
3. Leading questions: These are questions that suggest a particular answer
or point of view. For example, "Don't you think the main character was
wrong to do that?"
4. Probing questions: These are follow-up questions that teachers use to
encourage students to elaborate on their answers or provide more detail. For
example, "Can you give an example of how you would apply this concept in
real life?"
The teacher's role in asking questions is (1) to promote critical
thinking and encourage active participation in the classroom.
2. Teachers should use a
variety of question types to stimulate discussion and engage all students in
the learning process.
3. Additionally, they should
provide feedback and guide students in their responses to help them develop
their thinking skills and deepen their understanding of the subject matter.
4. Finally, teachers should
create a safe and respectful classroom environment where all students feel
comfortable asking and answering questions.
In summary, the nature of
classroom discourse is multifaceted and involves the use of oral language,
discussion as a tool for learning, and effective questioning techniques. By
using these strategies, teachers can create a positive and engaging learning
environment that promotes student learning and success.
5.4. Designing Teaching Manual for LAC
1. Details
2. Content Outline
3. Content Analysis:
Terms,
Facts and concepts
4. Curricular Objectives
5. Language Objectives: To develop learners listening,
speaking, reading and writing skills
6. Listening Outcome:
ü
Pupils
develop the competency in acquiring the knowledge of above-mentioned terms,
facts, and concepts.
ü
Pupils
develop competency in apply in the above concepts and process to analyses new
situation
7. Linguistic Outcome:
Ø
The
learners develop competency in speaking and expressing their view points
Ø
The
pupils develop competency in reading and comprehending the text.
8. Pre-requisite
9. Learning Strategy
10. learning Materials
11. Activity
Introductory Activity, developing activity, concluding
and follow-up activity with Reponses.