204.20 PEDAGOGICAL DIMENSIONS OF COMMERCE
Module
1 – Psychological Dimension of Commerce Teaching
1.1 Behaviorism- Implications
Behaviorism or the behavioral learning
theory is a popular concept that focuses on how students learn. This learning
theory states that behaviors are learned from the environment, and says that
innate or inherited factors have very little influence on behavior. A common
example of behaviorism is positive reinforcement. A student gets a
small treat if they get 100% on their spelling test.
Behaviorism started as a reaction
against introspective psychology in the 19th century, which relied heavily on
first-person accounts. J.B. Watson and B.F. Skinner rejected introspective
methods as being subjective and unquantifiable. These psychologists wanted to
focus on observable, quantifiable events and behaviors. They said that science
should take into account only observable indicators. They helped bring
psychology into higher relevance by showing that it could be accurately
measured and understood, and it wasn’t just based off opinions.
Watson and Skinner believed that if they were given a
group of infants, the way they were raised and the environment they put them in
would be the ultimate determining factor for how they acted, not their parents
or their genetics.
Pavlov’s Dog is a popular behaviorism experiment
(Classical conditioning). A group of dogs would hear a bell ring and then they
would be given food. After enough time, when the bell would ring the dogs would
salivate, expecting the food before they even saw it. This is exactly what
behaviorism argues—that the things we experience and our environment are the drivers
of how we act.
The stimulus-response sequence
is a key element of understanding behaviorism. A stimulus is given, for example
a bell rings, and the response is what happens next, a dog salivates or a
pellet of food is given. Behavioral learning theory argues that even complex
actions can be broken down into the stimulus-response.
Positive reinforcement is key in the behavioral
learning theory. Without positive reinforcement, students will quickly
abandon their responses because they don’t appear to be working. For example,
if students are supposed to get a sticker every time, they get an A on a test,
and then teachers stop giving that positive reinforcement, less students may
get A’s on their tests, because the behavior isn’t connected to a reward for
them.
Repetition and positive reinforcement go
hand-in-hand with the behavioral learning theory. Teachers often work to strike
the right balance of repeating the situation and having the positive
reinforcement come to show students why they should continue that
behavior.
Motivation plays an important role in behavioral
learning. Positive and negative reinforcement can be motivators for students.
For example, a student who receives praise for a good test score is much more
likely to learn the answers effectively than a student who receives no praise
for a good test score.
Educational Implications of Behaviorism
Teachers can implement behavioral learning strategy techniques in their
classroom in many ways, including:
·
Principles of classical conditioning can be used for developing good habits
in children such as cleanliness, respect for elders, punctuality etc. It also
can be used for breaking anxiety, fear and phobias.
·
The principle of operant conditioning may be successfully applied in the classroom
for the modification of undesirable behaviour of maladjusted children
·
Drills: Teachers may practice skills using drill patterns to help students
see the repetition and reinforcement that behavioral learning theory uses.
· Question and answer: Teachers
can use a question as a stimulus and answer as a response, gradually getting
harder with questions to help students.
· Guided practice: Teachers can
be directly involved in helping students go through problems to give them the
reinforcement and behavior demonstration you want them to follow.
· Regular review: Reviews are
important to behavioral learning theory. Going back over material and giving
positive reinforcement will help students retain information much better.
· Positive reinforcement:
Behaviorist classrooms utilize positive reinforcement regularly. This can be in
the form of verbal reinforcement and praise, reward systems, added privileges,
and more.
1.2. Constructivism,
Cognitive and social - implications
1.2.1 Constructivism
Constructivism is an important
learning theory that educators use to help their students
learn. Constructivism is based on the idea that people actively
construct or make their own knowledge, and that reality is determined by your
experiences as a learner. Basically, learners use their previous knowledge as a
foundation and build on it with new things that they learn. So, everyone's
individual experiences make their learning unique to them.
Principles
of Constructivism?
·
Knowledge
is constructed. This
is the basic principle, meaning that knowledge is built upon other knowledge.
Students take pieces and put them together in their own unique way, building
something different than what another student will build. The student’s
previous knowledge, experiences, beliefs, and insights are all important
foundations for their continued learning.
·
People
learn to learn, as they learn. Learning involves constructing meaning and systems of meaning. For
example, if a student is learning the chronology of dates for a series of
historical events, at the same time they are learning the meaning of
chronology.
·
Learning
is an active process.
Learning involves sensory input to construct meaning.
·
Learning
is a social activity.
Learning is directly associated to our connection with other people. Our
teachers, our family, or peers, and our acquaintances impact our learning.
·
Learning
is contextual.
Students don’t learn isolated facts and theories separate from the rest of our
lives—we learn in ways connected to things we already know, what we believe,
and more.
·
Knowledge
is personal. Because
constructivism is based on your own experiences and beliefs, knowledge becomes
a personal affair. Each person will have their own prior knowledge and
experiences to bring to the table. So, the way and things people learn and gain
from education will all be very different.
·
Learning
exists in the mind.
Hands-on experiences and physical actions are necessary for learning, but those
elements aren’t enough. Engaging the mind is key to successful learning.
Learning needs to involve activities for the minds, not just our hands. Mental
experiences are needed for retaining knowledge.
·
Motivation
is key to learning.
Students are unable to learn if they are unmotivated.
What are the three main Types of Constructivism?
Cognitive
constructivism based on the work of Jean Piaget, Social
constructivism based on the work of Lev Vygotsky, and Radical
constructivism.
1. Cognitive. Cognitive constructivism focuses on
the idea that learning should be related to the learner’s stage of cognitive
development. These methods work to help students in learning new information by
connecting it to things they already know, enabling them to make modifications
in their existing intelligence to accommodate the new information. Cognitive
constructivism comes from the work of Jean Piaget and his research on cognitive
development in children.
2. Social. Social constructivism focuses on the
collaborative nature of learning. Knowledge develops from how people interact
with each other, their culture, and society at large. Students rely on others
to help create their building blocks, and learning from others helps them
construct their own knowledge and reality. Social constructivism comes from Lev
Vygotsky, and is closely connected to cognitive constructivism with the added
element of societal and peer influence.
3. Radical. Radical constructivism is very
different from cognitive and social constructivism. It focuses on the idea that
learners and the knowledge they construct tell us nothing real, only help us
function in our environment. The overall idea is that knowledge is invented,
not discovered. The things we bring to the table make it impossible for us to
have truth, only interpretations of knowledge. This theory was developed by
Ernst von Glaser Feld in 1974.
Constructivism
in Education
It’s important to understand how teachers can apply constructivism
inside their classroom to create a unique learning environment for students.
1. In constructivist classrooms, the
teacher has a role to create a collaborative environment where students are
actively involved in their own learning.
2. Teachers are more facilitators of
learning than actual instructors. Teachers must work to understand the
pre-existing conceptions and understanding of students, then work to
incorporate knowledge within those areas. Teachers will also need to adjust
their teaching to match the learner’s level of understanding.
3. Constructivist classrooms rely on four
key areas to be successful:
·
Shared
knowledge between teachers and students.
·
Shared
authority between teachers and students.
·
Teachers
act as a guide or facilitator.
·
Learning
groups consist of small numbers of students.
Constructivist classrooms are often
very different from normal classrooms in many ways. Constructivist classrooms
focus on student questions and interests, they build on what students already
know, they focus on interactive learning and are student-centered, teachers
have a dialogue with students to help them construct their own knowledge, they
root in negotiation, and students work primarily in groups. Constructivist
classrooms often have teachers who do small group work, collaborative and
interactive activities, and open dialogues about what students need in order to
find success.
1.2.2. Cognitive Constructivism
It
states knowledge is something that is actively constructed by learners based on
their existing cognitive structures. Therefore, learning is relative to their
stage of cognitive development. Cognitivist teaching methods aim to assist
students in assimilating new information to existing knowledge, and enabling
them to make the appropriate modifications to their existing intellectual
framework to accommodate that information.
Cognitive Constructivism by Piaget
According to Piaget, knowledge is
not merely transmitted verbally but must be constructed and reconstructed by
the learner. He believed that learning involves certain processes. The
intellectual growth involves three fundamental processes.
Assimilation
Accommodation and
Equilibration
In assimilation,
the learner transforms incoming information so that it fits within his existing
schemes or thought patterns (incorporation of new events into preexisting
Cognitive structures). In accommodation, the learner adapts his thought
patterns to include incoming information (modification of existing cognitive
Structures to hold the new information). This dual process,
assimilation-accommodation, enables the child to form schema. Equilibration
involves the person striking a balance between himself and the environment,
between assimilation and accommodation. When a child experiences a new event,
disequilibrium sets in until he is able to assimilate and accommodate the new
information and thus attain equilibrium. There are many types of equilibrium
between assimilation and accommodation that vary with the levels of development
and the problems to be solved. For Piaget, equilibration is the Major factor in
explaining why some children advance more quickly in the development of logical
intelligence than do others.
Piaget discovered
that children think and reason differently at different periods in their lives.
Children who are at certain stage cannot be taught the concepts of a higher
stage. The four stages if cognitive development identified by Piaget are:
1. Sensori-motor stage
(Birth-2 yrs): The important accomplishments are:
·
Differentiates
self from objects
·
Recognizes
self as agent of action and begins to act intentionally: e.g. shakes a rattle
to make a noise
·
Achieves
object permanence: realizes that things continue to exis! even when no longer
present to the sense.
2. Pre-operational (2-7 years): The important accomplishments are:
·
Learns
to use language and to represent objects by images and words
·
Thinking
is still egocentric: has difficulty taking the viewpoint of others
·
Classifies
objects by a single feature: e.g. groups together all the red blocks regardless
of shape or all the square blocks regardless of colour
3.concrete operational stage
(7-11 years): The important
accomplishments are.
·
Can
think logically about objects and events
·
Achieves
conservation of number, mass, and weight
·
Classifies
objects according to several features and can order them in series along a
single dimension such as size.
4. Formal operational stage
(12-15 years): The important accomplishments
are:
·
Can
think logically about abstract propositions and test hypotheses systematically
·
Becomes
concerned with the hypothetical, the future, and ideological problems
Implications for Education
1. The school curriculum should
be enriched with diverse materials and activities.
2. Allow children to
opportunities for assimilation and accommodation
3. Children should have
opportunities to communicate with one another, to argue and debate. This way
teacher can assess child’s cognitive level, their strength and weakness.
4. Piaget saw teachers as
facilitators of knowledge (Guide and stimulate)
5. Allow children to make
mistakes and learn from them.
6. Laboratories, workshop and
technologies that encourage interactivity by using multimedia
1.2.3 Social Constructivism of
Vygotsky
The theory of social
constructivism is proposed by Lev Semyonovich Vygotsky (1896-1934), a Russian
psychologist, who applied the Marxist social theory to individual psychology.
The social constructivist theory considers learning as a social and
communicative process whereby knowledge is shared and understandings are
constructed in culturally formed social settings. It emphasizes the importance
of culture and context in understanding what occurs in society and constructing
knowledge based on this understanding. Vygotsky’s social constructivism is
based on the following four basic principles:
a) Children construct their
knowledge
b) Development cannot be
separated from its social context
c) Learning can lead to
development
d) Language plays a central role
in mental development
The important
components of the social constructivist theory proposed by Vygotsky are
discussed under different sub-heads:
1. Construction of knowledge
occurs only when the learner interacts in a social context: (interactions with
surrounding culture and a more knowledgeable person such as parents, teachers
and more competent peers) ' lead to constant changes in a child’s thought and
behavior.
2. Learning occurs through the
internalization of a socially negotiated mental function:
3. Language is a tool for
understanding outer world and constructing knowledge.
4. Intentional learning is
limited to the zone of proximal development (ZPD). It is the difference
between the child’s capacity to solve problems on his own, and his capacity to
solve them with assistance. In other words, ZPD is the gap between the actual
development and potential development. The full development during the ZPD
depends upon full social interaction and the more the child takes advantages of
an adult’s assistance, the broader is its ‘Zone of Proximal Development’.
Educational Implications
1. The curriculum should be
designed to emphasize interaction between learners and learning tasks.
2. Vygotsky’s theory emphasizes
the need of students to construct their own understanding of each concept, so
that the primary role of teacher is to create social situations for students
that will foster the construction of knowledge.
3. All the components of the
educational process should be framed in tune with the culture of the society.
4. Social constructivism
considers the teacher as a co-learner.
5. Social constructivism
considers scaffolding (supporting/helping) as an effective form of
teaching. For this to achieve, the teacher should continually adjust the level
of his help in response to the learner’s level of performance.
6. The theory advices peer
instruction, guided instruction, cooperative learning, social negotiation and
collaborative learning as specialized methods of teaching and learning.
7. The physical classroom, based
on Vygotsky’s theory, would provide clustered desks or tables and work space
for peer instruction, collaboration (team-work), and small group instruction.
8. Social constructivist method
of teaching necessitates the design of learning materials in such a way to
encourage student interaction and collaboration.
9. According to Vygotskey,
learning is limited to ZPD, the difference between learner’s actual development
and his potential development. Hence, the assessment methods must target both
the level of actual development and the level of potential development.
10. Two children can differ
substantially in the ZPD’s. Therefore, a knowledge of the ZPD will help the
teacher to identify each child’s readiness to benefit from instruction.
Difference between Behaviorism and
Constructivism
No |
Behaviorism |
Constructivism |
1 |
Teacher centered education |
Learner centered education |
2 |
content oriented |
Process oriented |
3 |
emphasizes teaching |
Emphasizes Learning |
4 |
Learner as a receiver of Knowledge |
Learner with unique abilities |
5 |
Learning as a mechanical process |
Learning as a natural process |
6 |
Learning is stimulus-response relationship |
Learning as active mental process |
7 |
Learner as empty vessels |
Learning with unique abilities |
8 |
Same approach for all age groups |
Chang approach based on developmental stages |
9 |
Extrinsic motivation leads to learning |
Intrinsic motivation leads to learning |
10 |
Rewards, punishments, reinforcement make
learning effective |
Problem solving through experiences makes
learning effective |
11 |
Learning is behavior modification |
Learning is conceptual change & addition |
12 |
Does not consider learner’s mental models |
Considers learner’s mental model |
13 |
Importance to product of learning |
Importance to process of learning |
14 |
It based on behaviorist theories of learning |
Based on cognitive theories |
15 |
Teacher’s role as a trainer |
Teacher’s role as a facilitator |
1.3.
THEORIES OF MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCE
Theory of Multiple Intelligence (Howard Gardner
1983): Howard Gardner, the American Psychologist proposed a theory that sought
to broaden the traditional definition of intelligence which is defined by
mental tests. Gardner argued that we do not have one underlying general
intelligence, but we have multiple intelligences each being controlled by an
independent system in the brain. Gardner has identified eight intelligences,
each indicating special strength in a particular area. The theory implies that
traditional school education used to neglect a large potential of human by
passing judgements about children in terms of the general concept of
intelligence and thereby neglecting the special types of abilities in various
areas possessed by them.
“Intelligence is the ability to
find and solve problems and create products of value in one’s own culture”. -
Howard Gardner. He also suggested the possible addition of
a ninth known as "existentialist intelligence."
According to him normal humans possess all abilities in various degrees but 2
or 3 components which determines their behavior. The nine different
intelligences formulated by the theory of multiple intelligences are briefly
discussed below.
1. LINGUISTIC INTELLIGENCE is the capacity to use
words effectively whether orally or in writing.
Characteristics:
* Enjoys saying, hearing and seeing words.
* Likes telling stories.
* Gets motivated by books, records, dramas, and opportunities for
writing.
Strategies appropriate for Teaching Linguistic
Learner:
* Read out plays, poetry aloud
* Let him write a story for a book a magazine and keep a journal.
* Choral reading.
* Let the learners read passages to one other
* Read a portion and explain what they have read.
2. LOGICAL / MATHEMATICAL INTELLIGENCE is the capacity to use
numbers effectively and to reason well.
Characteristics:
·
Enjoys exploring how things are related
·
Likes to understand how things work
·
Like mathematical concepts
·
Enjoys puzzles and manipulative games.
·
Good at critical thinking.
Teaching Logical/Mathematical Learner:
·
Play games that require logical thinking
·
Work with scrambled sentences.
·
Arrange pictures in logical sequences
·
After reading, construct mind map arranging some of
the ideas and details.
3. VISUAL / SPATIAL INTELLIGENCE is the ability to perceive
the visual - spatial world accurately and perform accordingly and to make
transformations upon those perceptions.
Characteristics:
* Remembers things visually
* Likes posters, charts, graphics
*Likes any kind of visual clues.
* Enjoys drawing.
Teaching visual/Spatial Learner:
·
Study and create maps, diagrams and graphs.
·
Take a survey, put the information in a chart
·
Write words vertically
·
Cut out words from a magazine and use them in a
letter.
·
Use pictures to stimulate reading or writing
·
Use crossword puzzles.
4. BODILY / KINESTHETIC INTELLIGENCE is the expertise in using
one’s whole body to express ideas and feelings and facility in using one’s hand
to produce or transform things.
Characteristics:
* Like to move, dance, walk, swim etc.
* Good at sports
* Have good motor skills
* Likes to take things apart and put back together.
Teaching the Bodily/Kinaesthetic Learner:
* Use magnetic letters, letter blocks or letters on index cards to spell
words.
*Take a walk while discussing a story
* Use whole arm to write letters in the air
5. MUSICAL INTELLIGENCE is the capacity to
perceive, discriminate, transform and express musical forms.
Characteristics:
* Like the rhythm and sound of the language
* Likes poems, songs.
* Enjoys humming or singing along with music
Teaching the Musical Learner:
* Use a familiar tune; song or rap beat to teach
* Create a poem with an emphasis on certain sounds for pronunciation.
* Choral reading to work on fluency and intonation.
6. INTER PERSONAL INTELLIGENCE is the ability to perceive
and make distinctions in the moods, intentions, motivations and feelings of
other people.
Characteristics:
* Likes to develop ideas and learn from other people
* Likes to talk
* Have good social skills
Teaching Inter personal Learner:
* Take part in group discussions
* Read a dialogue or play together with peers
* Do team learning / investigating projects
* Set up interview questions and interview peers
* Write notes to one another instead of talking
7. INTRAPERSONAL INTELLIGENCE is the ability to sense
oneself
Characteristics:
* Has good sense of self
* Likes to think things over
* Likes independent projects and
learning by trial and error
Teaching Intrapersonal Learner:
·
Set aside time to reflect on new ideas and
information
·
Encourage journal writing
·
Work on the computer
·
Use brain-storming methods
·
Read inspirational books.
8. NATURALISTIC INTELLIGENCE is the ability to
understand the natural world including plants, animals and details of
scientific studies related to natural phenomena; to recognise and classify
individuals, species and ecological relations; to interact effectively with
living creations.
Characteristics:
·
Skill for understanding animal behaviour, needs,
characteristics etc.
·
Works with plants
·
Knowledge of natural living energy forces
Teaching the Naturalistic Learner:
* Take field trips
* Here speeches on natural phenomena made by Guest speakers
* Keep pets, live corners
* Engage in Science experiments
9. Existential Intelligence
Existential intelligence involves an
individual's ability to use collective values and intuition to understand others and the world around
them. People who excel in this intelligence typically are able to
see the big picture. Characteristics
may include:
·
maintain
a longer-term outlook
·
take into account
the internal and external conductions
·
set a general
direction
·
Align resources and inspire others
The new approach adopted in line with the viewpoint about the nature and components of human intelligence has to be reflected in the teaching and learning of Commerce also. Providing appropriate learning situation and activities should cater to each component given above. At the same time the fact that all these are interrelated and hence could be considered while handling any learning material should also be considered. The activities should help the learner to foster as many types of intelligence as possible.
F. THEORY OF MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES AND COMMERCE
EDUCATION
Theory of Multiple Intelligence can be very
effectively used in a Commerce classroom. Few tips for the application of the
various components of MI in Commerce classroom are given in the following
table.
Components Of MI |
Activities appropriate to Commerce Education |
Linguistic/Verbal |
Writing stories/narrations regarding various
business aspects like, partnership, sole proprietorship, accounting of
partnership firms, etc. Explaining how to work out a problem to others. Actively participating in debates, discussions,
etc. on various topics of Commerce. Preparing of project reports, assignments, etc. Writing scripts for radio lessons, dramatizations
etc. |
Bodily/Kinesthetic |
Performing in role plays/dramas, etc. Enacting the process of the treatment of goodwill
while a partner is retiring from a partnership firm. |
Musical Rhythmic intelligence |
Learning different aspects related to commerce in
a rhythmic manner. Preparing of musical presentations of various
topics in commerce |
Inter personal |
Solving complex problems/tasks together with a
group Participating in seminars, discussion,
interviews, etc. Describing/explaining a process to others, and
clearing their doubts. |
Intrapersonal |
Developing one's own thinking pattern for solving
a problem. Thinking, how to solve a problem in a different way. Linking subject with real life situations, Solving problems/ finding causes according to
change in mood. |
Naturalistic |
Studying the role of a business on environmental
pollution. |
SCOPE OF MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCE IN ACCOUNTANCY
Topic: Accounting Equations
Instructional Activities |
Scope involved in components of Multiple
Intelligence |
An accounting transaction is given by the teacher
to students together with a draft balance sheet of a joint stock company. The
transaction is: Ram commence a business with a cash worth 5,00,000 /- Teacher motivates students to identify the
following items from the given balance sheet and analyse its effects, a. Assets - current and fixed b. Liabilities c. Capital Teacher creates a brain storming session to reach
students about the relationship of asset, capital and liabilities as ASSETS = CAPITAL + LIABILITIES |
Logical/Mathematical Intelligence |
Teacher provides additional transactions relating
to business concerns and asks them to analyse each transaction by forming an
equation through small group discussion. |
Interpersonal Intelligence |
“Teacher creates business situations represent
the equation of accounting by exhibiting a model of accounting representing
“Duality Concept of Accounting”. |
Visual/Spatial intelligence |
Students provides some paper cut-outs each
represents stock, sundry debtors, sundry creditors, bills payable, bills
receivable, profit, capital, loan, interest, furniture and fittings,
building. Also provides a model of Common Balance as instructional support
for students. |
Bodily Kinesthetic intelligence |
Asks each student to fix the assets and
liabilities systematically and logically to make it as equal like common
balance. |
Logical/Mathematical intelligence |
Teacher provides a follow up activity: Visit a
sole trading concern, collect 10 transactions and analyse it effects by
applying accounting equations and present a summary accordingly |
Intrapersonal intelligence Interpersonal intelligence |
MODULE 2: PLANNING FOR INSTRUCTION
2.1Meaning, Need and Importance of Lesson Planning
Planning is
very important in instruction as in any enterprise. Adopting a top-down
planning strategy, there are three
levels to the planning of instruction. The plan of instruction for a particular academic year of a particular
subject is decided at the beginning of the year. There are several factors that are to be considered
in the process of planning.
Goods define lesson plan as: “Outline of the important points of a lesson arranged
in the order in which they
are to be presented to students by the teacher.” For a successful and effective teaching
planning is the first and the most important step. The teacher
should know beforehand what to teach and how to teach. S/he should have the clear aim
of the lesson before her/him and
should plan accordingly. S/he should know how s/he should introduce and present
the lesson and the aids s/he will
make use of. S/he should also know how to evaluate the lesson in the light of
the aim set.
IMPORTANCE OF LESSON PLANNING
1. It keeps the
teacher to be systematic and orderly in the treatment of the subject
matter.
2. Teacher proceeds
on well-thought of and definite
lines and does not follow haphazard and thoughtless teaching.
3. The teacher sets forth with some definite aims in view of students’
interest, attitudes, etc.,
through certain activities or
some other means.
4. Planning a lesson give confidence and self-reliance to the teacher
which is of great value
for successful teaching.
5. It saves time.
6. Because the lesson is correlated with the social
and physical environments of the students, their interest is maintained throughout the lesson.
Good Planning….
·
Keeps the teacher
and students on the track
·
Achieves
the objectives
·
Helps the teacher
to avoid unpleasant surprises.
·
Provides
the roadmaps and visuals in a logical
sequence
·
Provides
direction to a substitute.
·
Is based upon the previous knowledge.
·
Uses motivational techniques
·
Includes
necessary materials
·
Is student centered,
flexible, complete, interesting and activity
based.
·
Has proportionate
time allocation
·
Includes
evaluation process
·
Provides
information for the use of A.V
aids.
·
Provides
assignment for the students.
Purposes of
Lesson Plan
·
Structure the lesson
·
Organize its contents.
·
Determine the method of delivery.
·
Assess students
learning.
·
Evaluate its applications
Instructional planning
is a process of deciding what to teach and how to teach during the
teaching-learning process. Instructional planning helps the teacher to
construct goals, objectives, and instructional and assessment methodology for
the classroom. It is systematic planning that helps in developing, evaluating,
and managing the instructional process during the classroom process.
Principles of Instructional
Planning:
- Instructional planning is important for
understanding the basis of the course in the context of the educational
institution.
- To determine what content to be included in
the course concerning set objectives.
- To complete the subject matter at the
specified time.
2.2. Different Types of Plans-
Year Plan, Unit Plan, Lesson Plan
Based on the plan of instruction for the whole academic year, unit and lesson plan are
developed. This planning of instruction has three levels. They are Year plan, Unit plan, and Lesson plan
1. Year Plan
A year plan is a plan for an academic
year. Planning for the whole year’s
work as part of the pedagogic analysis is known as year plan. Based on the number
of working days in each term (quarter) the number of class periods
available to teach a particular subject is estimated. The time that will be spent on co-curricular
activities, vacation in each term, local holidays, study holidays and examination days are to be taken into account. Then
the time available is distributed
among the different units (chapters) included in the syllabus. Thus, the year plan stipulates the time available (in number of class periods)
to teach each unit, the month in which each
unit will be taught and the
relative weightages to the instructional objectives in each unit
Steps in year planning
1. Formation of units (organize subject matter into
different chapters)
2. Determining Objectives (setting priorities on
knowledge, understanding, skill, appreciation, interest, attitude etc.)
3. Scheduling of the time available for instruction
(class periods)
In short, Course plan/Year
plan is a plan of instruction in which planning of the whole content can be
done before the commencement of the course. The course plan provides the
details of the content, skills, and sometimes, values to be taught for the entire
course. It is a long-range teacher guide.
Format of Year Plan
Subject: Standard:
School: Year:
No |
Unit |
No: of class periods |
Month |
Term |
|
|
|
|
|
2. Unit Plan: After the course
plan, the unit plan can be prepared by the teacher. A unit plan consists of many
lessons and is longer than a lesson plan. A unit plan has five sections i.e.,
introduction, objectives, contents, hints for teachers, and evaluation. The topic
is the smallest unit of a unit plan.
Unit planning is an important aspect
in the planning of instruction. One
of the importance of a unit plan is that it breaks up the year’s work into
small sections which students can
understand and overview.
Steps in Unit Planning
1. Selection and systematization of the unit
2. Content analysis, 3. Determination of objectives 4. Learning experience
5. Selection of teaching aids 6. Evaluation 7. Assignment
Format of Unit Plan
I.
Name of the teacher:
Standard:
Subject: Unit:
Duration:
II.
Introduction on the unit
III.
Curricular
objectives
IV.
Content analysis
V.
Pre- requisites VI.
Content Outline |
Curricular Objectives |
Learning Strategies |
Leaning Activities |
Learning Materials |
Duration
|
Evaluation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
VII.
Follow up Activities
VIII. Enrichment Activities
3. Lesson Plan: A lesson plan is a plan of action
A lesson plan is a
teacher's plan for teaching an individual lesson. The lesson plan is the guide
of the teacher which includes the aims, objectives, subject matter, materials,
devices to be used, etc. during the teaching-learning process. A lesson plan
also helps in deciding the teaching methods and techniques and evaluation for
achieving the desired results.
Need for lesson Planning
1. To give a definite direction to the
teacher for each day’s work
2. To make the teacher thorough with the
content and to enable him develop confidence
3. To plan for maintaining links between
different lessons for teaching a particular unit and between the various
learning materials in the same lesson.
4. To specify well defined goals to be
realised in the course of the lesson.
5. To prevent waste of time due to lack of
pre-planning.
6. To decide upon appropriate learning
activities and use of instructional materials.
7. To decide upon procedures for gathering
feedback and for providing reinforcement.
8. To anticipate probable difficulties and to
plan remedial measures
9. To plan evaluational procedures both
formative and summative
Advantages
of lesson planning
Ø We can present the learning
material in a logical, systematic and effective way.
Ø We can obtain adequate coverage
of content.
Ø We can identify the
relevant and appropriate objectives to be realised by instruction.
Ø We can realise the
instructional objectives effectively.
Ø We can ensure economy of
time, material and effort.
Ø We will develop
self-confidence and pride in our work.
Ø We can impart quality
instruction.
Ø We get opportunities to
experiment with our own ideas.
Ø We can maintain orderliness
and system in the instructional process.
2.3. Approaches in Lesson
Planning (Behavioural and Constructive)
A. Behaviourist Approaches in lesson planning
There are various
behaviourist approaches of lesson planning based on behaviourist theories. The
important among them are...
1. The Herbartian Approach
2. Gloverian approach, 3. Evaluation
approach, 4. Unit approach (not in syllabus)
5. RCEM Approach
1. Herbartian Approach
The great German
philosopher and educationist Sir. John Fredrick Herbart (1776 1841) and his
followers developed this approach which consists of the following four steps. 1.
Clearness (Preparation) ii. Association (Presentation) iii. System (Abstract)
iv. Method (Application). These steps were further modified by his disciples
as:
1. Preparation: This step is concerned with preparation of the
mind of learners for receiving a new knowledge. Here the teacher has to check
the related knowledge which the learner has already acquired. At this stage,
the teacher should plan for the presentation of the content.
ii. Presentation: It is the stage at which the learning materials
and learning experiences are gradually presented in the sequential order. The
new ideas or knowledge of content is imparted in such a way that it may be
linked with the already familiar knowledge of the students. Here the teacher
should follow a definite structure of learning activities and impart specific
content.
iii, Association and
Comparison: This stage is meant for
providing opportunity for comparing related ideas and for establishing linkages
or associations. This would help in gaining holistic knowledge in the place of
various learning points presented as pieces of information.
iv. Generalization: If the third stage is executed effectively, the
pupils develop the ability to establish new relations by comparison and
reflection, and thus to deduce generalisation. This makes the knowledge
thorough.
v. Application: Here the teacher creates situations or problems
so that student can apply the generalised ideas and concepts in new situations.
This would facilitate transfer of knowledge to many related, but novel
situations. This would also facilitate acquisition of new knowledge and skills.
vi. Recapitulation: This is the last step. The understanding
comprehension of the subject matter as well as the ability to apply these
taught by the teacher can be reviewed by putting some suitable questions on the
topic. This recapitulation helps consolidation of the knowledge acquired and
also remediation in case of gaps, if any, noted.
5. RCEM Approach
This approach was
developed by the Regional College of Education, Mysore (RCEM). This is
an improvement of the earlier approaches. This approach adopts ideas suggested
in Bloom's Taxonomy of Educational objectives. The design of lesson plan according
to this approach consists of three steps.
i. Inputs stage, ii. Process stage iii,
Output stage
1. Input stage
It includes the
identification of objectives. They are known as Expected Behavioural Outcomes
(EBOs). These objectives are broadly classified into four categories -
knowledge, understanding, application and creativity. These objectives are
written in behavioural terms by employing seventeen mental abilities. The
entering behaviour of the learners is also identified. The sequence of instructional
procedure is determined with the help of these objectives.
ii. Process stage
At this stage, the
teaching strategies are selected for achieving these objectives. The
communication strategy and audio-visual aids are employed for the effective
presentation of the content. The main focus of the process is to create the
learning situations for providing appropriate learning experiences to the students.
The process also includes the technique of motivation so that student’s
behaviour can be reinforced for the desirable responses. It implies the
interaction of teacher and Students. The participation of pupil and teacher is
also an essential feature.
III. Output Stage
This stage of
instructional procedure includes evaluation of change in behaviour or Real
Learning Outcomes (RLOs). The various measuring devices are employed for
evaluating the RLOs. These measuring instruments are constructed on the basis
of EBOs. The teacher usually measures the RLOs by using oral and written questions.
B. Lesson Planning under
Constructivist Approach
From the year 2005-06
onwards, the curriculum transaction at the higher secondary level has been
changed from a teacher centred one to a learner centered one. Objective
based instruction based on behaviourist approach is transformed to a competency-based
constructivist approach. Here the teacher is acting as a scaffolder and a
consultant. This approach of lesson planning is based on curriculum objectives.
The details regarding curriculum objectives is given below. |
Curricular Objectives: The instructional process is
always objective based. The objectives which are framed out of Curricular
material is known as Curricular Objectives. These consist of three aspects such
as Competencies, Process, and Output. Teacher is setting the competencies,
which are to be attained by the learner, and giving activities which enable the
learner to attain the competencies. These activities help the learner to
experience a process, which helps them to construct knowledge. This kind of
construction of knowledge helps them for a self-transformation. That is, from a
‘learner’ to a ‘learner with desirable behavioural changes’ or output. These behavioural
changes can be evaluated with the help of a mediator only. These mediators can
be Project reports, Seminar reports, Notes, etc. prepared by the learners as
evidence for the acquisition of behavioural changes.
For example, a curriculum
objective like “Analyses the ethical values of a business through seminar,
discussion and prepares notes’, includes “Analyses the ethical values of the
business” as competency, “Seminar and discussion” as the process, and the
product will be the report prepared by the learner.
While planning, teacher
should analyse the curricular objectives and based on this he should proceed
for the preparation of plans. The activities should be planned on the basis of
the detailed analysis of the curricular objectives. To frame a curricular
objective, the teacher should systematically integrate the content with its
instructional process and the way for evaluation ie., it is the sum total of
content + process + evaluation.
Module 3
Evaluation in Commerce Teaching and Learning
3.1.
Construction of Achievement Test, Diagnostic Test and Remediation
Achievement Test
Achievement
tests are conducted by the teacher to test the scholastic achievement of learner at the end of unit or course.
They have their
own limitations. They cannot be used to compare the performance of students of one school
with that of the other. For this purpose,
standardized achievements tests
are used. The items of this
kind of test are based on the content and objectives common
to a number of schools which are to be compared.
Achievement test construction
1- Planning of The Test
Before constructing an achievement test, the test constructor should think about the following
aspects as part of planning. Purpose
of the test, Time
for the test, Maximum and minimum mark, Nature
and scope of questions,
Units to be selected
2- Preparation of A Design for The Test
After determining the broad scope of the test, a design has to be developed tune with it. Mainly four factors are to be considered while designing a test.
a. weightage to objective,
b. Weightage to content
c.
Weightage to forms of questions d. Weightage to difficulty level
a. Weightage to objectives
This indicates what objectives are to
be tested and what weightage has to be given to each objective. The weightage
should be decided according to the relative importance of objectives and nature of the content.
Sl.No. |
Objectives |
Marks |
Percentage |
1 |
Knowledge |
5 |
10 |
2 |
Understanding |
15 |
30 |
3 |
Application |
20 |
40 |
4 |
Skills |
10 |
20 |
|
Total |
50 |
100 |
b. Weightage to Content
This
indicates the various
aspects of the content and the weightage
to be given to those different aspects. All the content should be
covered and proper weightage should be given to each content according to their relative
importance.
Sl.No. |
Content |
Marks |
Percentage |
1 |
Unit-1 |
10 |
20 |
2 |
Unit-2 |
11 |
22 |
3 |
Unit-3 |
19 |
38 |
4 |
Unit-4 |
10 |
20 |
|
Total |
50 |
100 |
C. Weightage to forms of questions
This
indicates the forms of the items to be included
in the test and the weightage to be
given for each. The setter should select those forms of questions that are
suitable to the objectives and content to be tested.
Sl.No. |
Form of Questions |
No. of questions |
Marks |
Percentage |
1 |
Objective |
25 |
25 |
50 |
2 |
Short answer |
5 |
15 |
30 |
3 |
Essay |
1 |
10 |
20 |
|
Total |
31 |
50 |
100 |
d. Weightage to Difficulty level
Appropriate weightage should be given for different levels of difficult
of the item. The test should cater to the bright, the average and the
dull.
Sl.No. |
Difficulty Level |
Marks |
Percentage |
1 |
Easy |
15 |
30 |
2 |
Average |
25 |
50 |
3 |
Difficult |
10 |
20 |
|
Total |
50 |
100 |
3. Preparation of Blueprint
A blue print gives the details of the design in concrete terms. Blue print is prepared as a three-dimensional chart indicating the distribution of questions objective wise, content
wise and form wise. The
following table shows the blueprint for an achievement test (the number outside
the bracket indicates the marks and those inside indicate the number of questions).
Sl. No. |
Content |
Curricular Objectives |
Mental Processes |
Forms of Questions |
Total Score |
||
O |
SA
|
LA
|
|||||
1 |
Unit-1 Company |
1,2 |
3,4,6,7 |
(2) 1 |
(2) 3 |
- |
8 |
2 |
Unit-2 Issue of
shares |
3 |
1,6,7,8 |
(1) 1 |
(1) 3 |
(1) 4 |
8 |
3 |
Unit-3 Types of
shares |
4 |
1,2,5,10 |
(3) 1 |
(2) 2 |
- |
7 |
4 |
Unit-4 Forfeiture
of shares |
5,6 |
1,5,7,9 |
(1) 1 |
(1) 2 |
(1) 4 |
7 |
|
Total score |
|
|
7 |
15 |
8 |
30 |
Note: O= Objective type, SA=
Short Answer, LA= Long Answer. Figure inside the bracket shows no. of questions
and outside shows scores for each question.
4.Writing of Items
The blue print gives a very clear idea about the number of questions to
be written from each topic, their forms and objectives. With this precise
directive suggested by the
blue-print the paper setter can start writing item according to the
requirements. While writing the items, the difficulty level should be considered. Whether
all questions can be answered within the time allotted should also be
considered. Test item construction demand mastery of content and technique of
constructing each type of questions. If a
pool of well-prepared items in the form of a Question Bank is available, the
constructor can easily choose the required number of items for the test in tune
with the specifications of the blue print.
After writing the
preliminary details such as the name of the examination, title of the paper,
maximum marks and time, instruction for answering each part, etc. the setter
has to arrange the questions already written. It is advisable to arrange
questions in the order of their difficulty level. Normally, knowledge-items
will be easier than an understanding items, which in turn may be easier than an
application item. This need not be always true, but may be taken as a clue for
arranging questions in a test. Items for each section can then be arranged.
5. Preparation of the Scoring Key
and the Marking Scheme:
In order to maintain
objectivity, scoring should be made strictly in accordance with a predesigned
scheme of evaluation. So, it is essential to prepare the scoring key and the
marking scheme Simultaneously with the question paper. In the case of objective
type items where the answers are in the form of some letter or other symbol, a
scoring key is prepared. Normally no practical credit is given for an objective
type item. In the case of short answer and essay type questions, the marking
scheme is prepared. In preparing marking scheme what the examiner has to do is
to list out the value points to be credited and then to fix up the mark to be
given to each value point. Clearly writing the value points will also help to
identify defects, if any, that might have accidently crept into the test items
and these could be corrected before the final test is released.
Usually, general
instructions also are given at the end of the scheme of valuation in order to
avoid subjectivity in scoring. Here indication may be given as to the penalty
for committing errors, spelling mistakes, grammatical mistakes, etc.
6. Preparation of Question-wise
Analysis:
In order to avoid all
loopholes, the setter prepares a table containing all relevant details of all
the items of the test. This is done by making an analysis of each item in terms
of objective, specification, form o question, difficulty level, marks and
estimated time. This analysis is very helpful to check whether all the aspects
envisaged in the design and blue-print are satisfied by the test in its final
form. If some mistake is noticed it should be rectified at this final stage. |
Characteristics of an achievement
test
1. It measures how much a student has: achieved.
2. It gives due weightage to objectives, content,
forms of questions and difficulty levels in a general way.
3. It gives proportional weightage to each and every
topic prescribed by the curriculum in a broad manner.
4. It strictly observes the time factor that is,
achievement is assessed through the performance of the student within a span of
time allotted. No extra time is allowed.
5. The level of performance in an achievement test is
generally measured in terms of marks or scores.
6. Marks scored are crucial in an achievement test.
This is because, it aims at placement of pupils in the group concerned
according to ranks.
Functions of an achievement test
1. To see how effectively the teaching and learning
have taken place.
2. To motivate students before a new assignment is
taken up.
3. To provide basis for promotion to the next stage.
4. To help in determining the relative position of
each student in a particular group.
CONSTRUCTION
OF DIAGNOSTIC TEST AND REMEDIATION
Diagnostic test
It “is a test designed to identify and investigate the difficulties, disabilities, in- adequacies and gaps of pupils in specific curriculum areas with a view to helping them to overcome these difficulties through remedial instructions.”
The term
diagnosis has been borrowed from the medical profession. It means
identification of disease
by means of patient’s symptoms. For example, when a patient comes to a doctor, the doctor initially puts some questions to the patient to gather
some basic information’s about the disease
and then uses other techniques to get more related information to identify
the disease and its probable
cause(s).
After
careful analysis of these data, he prescribes the medicines as remedial
treatment. Similarly, in the field
of education, diagnosis has many such implications. Difficulties in learning occur
frequently at all levels and among pupils
of both high and low mental
ability.
In order
to handle such cases, the teacher also uses similar techniques like a doctor to diagnose
the relative strengths and weaknesses of pupil in the specific area of study, analyze
the causes for the same and then provides remedial measures as per necessity.
Since
tools and techniques used in mental measurements are not that exact, objective and precise like the tools and
techniques used in sciences, the
teachers are cautioned to use the diagnostic data with great care for designing remedial programmes.
But it is used in education to determine the learning difficulties or
deficiencies of the
learner. Diagnostic test is a test used to diagnose strength and weakness of
the learning in certain areas of study whereas diagnostic evaluation is
centered on schooling process such as the curriculum programme, administration
and so on.
When
learning difficulties that are left unresolved by the standard corrective prescriptions of formative evaluation and a pupil
continues to experience failure despite the use of prescribed alternative
methods of instruction, then a more
detailed diagnosis is indicated.
To
use a medical analogy, formative testing
provides first aid treatment for simple learning problems and diagnostic
testing searches for the underlying causes of those problems that do not respond
to first aid treatment.
Thus it is much more comprehensive and detailed and the difference lies in the types of question each of them is
addressing.
The following are the salient features of Diagnostic Testing:
(i)
The diagnostic test takes up where
the formative test leaves off.
(ii)
A diagnostic test is a means by which an individual profile
is examined and compared against
certain norms or criteria.
(iii)
Diagnostic test focuses on individual’s educational weakness or learning deficiency and identify the gaps in pupils.
(iv)
Diagnostic test is more intensive and act as a tool for analysis
of Learning Difficulties.
(v)
Diagnostic test is more often limited to low ability
students.
(vi)
Diagnostic test is corrective in nature.
(vii)
Diagnostic test pinpoints the specific types of error each pupil is making and
searches for underlying causes of the problem.
(viii)
Diagnostic test is much more comprehensive.
(ix)
Diagnostic test helps us to identify
the trouble spots and discovered those areas of student’s weakness that are unresolved by formative test.
Purpose of Diagnostic test
•
To identify the strength and weakness in individual with in a subject field
•
To identify the cause for poor achievement
•
To identify the learning difficulty associated with the student
•
To get an awareness of the behavioural and scholastic problems of the child
•
To find out appropriate remedial measures to
solve the problem
Types of Diagnostic test
•
Pre-diagnostic test
•
Post-diagnostic test
Construction of Diagnostic Test
The following are the
broad steps involved in the construction of a diagnostic test. Diagnostic Test
may be Standardized or Teacher made and more or less followed the principles of
test construction i.e., preparation, planning, writing items, assembling the
test, preparing the scoring key and marking scheme and reviewing the test.
The Unit on which a
Diagnostic Test is based should be broken into learning points without omitting
any of the item and various types of items of test is to be prepared in a proper
sequence. Objective type test item is sufficient and easily locate area of
difficulty in a proper manner. The procedure involves:
1, Analysis of the context
minutely i.e., major and minor one.
2. Forming questions on each minor
concept (recall and recognition type) in order of difficulty.
3. Review the test items by the
experts/experienced teacher to modify or delete test items if necessary.
4. Administering the test.
5. Scoring the test and analysis
of the results.
6. Identification of weakness
7. Identify the causes of
weakness (such as defective hearing or vision, poor home conditions,
unsatisfactory relations with classmates or teacher, lack of ability) by the
help of interview, questionnaires, peer information, family, class teacher,
doctor or past records.
8. Suggest remedial programme (No
set pattern).
Advantages
•
To find out difficulties of students in learning a specific area.
•
Identifies the causes result in poor achievement.
•
Finding
problems before it become a serious problem for
students, parents & teachers.
•
Can give remedial instructions appropriately.
•
It is essential for effective
learning.
•
It is highly useful in educational evaluation.
•
Helps the learner
to overcome his difficulties in certain area/ subject.
Limitations
•
Highly time consuming.
•
Work-load for teachers.
•
Large amount of resources and trained teachers are required.
ACHIEVEMENT TEST |
DIAGNOSIS TEST |
•
Measures how much a student
has achieved.
•
Give due weightage to objective, content. •
Give due weightage to every topic in the content area •
Strictly observes time factor •
For
the purpose of promotion •
Test arranged in the order of difficulty level of items. •
Construction is easy as per pre- determined steps |
•
Measures how much a student has not been achieved and why •
Consider everything – that is done
in a critical and analytical way. •
Give greater emphasis to the aspect with potential difficulty. •
Not concerned with the time factor. •
For the purpose of identifying the difficulties. •
Arranged in the order of
learning sequence. •
Construction of the test
requires more imagination. |
Remedial Instruction/Teaching
When
once exact nature of the difficulties and reasons are known, the teacher has to take steps for remedial instruction. It can
be in the Group level or Individual level depending upon the scope of
diagnosis.
Special Features of Remedial Instruction
·
It is a process of instruction that follows immediately
after the diagnostic test.
·
Teacher plans strategies for remedial teaching
on the basis of nature
of the difficulties and reasons behind
it.
·
Teacher provides additional learning experience to compensate the difficulty.
·
Remedial instruction is based on the type of difficulties.
·
Diagnosis and remedial instruction should be continuous and integral part of
effective instruction.
Diagnosis and Remediation:
Diagnosis is concerned with the persistent/ recurring learning
difficulties that are left
unresolved by the standard corrective prescription of formative assessment.
Remediation on the basis of the difficulties it is also a function
of evaluation.
3.2 Types
of Test items- Merits and Demerits
A written
test is composed of a number of test items- Essay type, Short answer type and Objective type.
1. Objective Type
An objective type of test item is one in which the response will be objective. The different types of
objective items are true-false type, multiple choice type, matching type and completion type.
Multiple Choice
Question: It is the most popular test item. It has
two parts. The first part of the item
is called STEM presented in the form of an incomplete sentence or an interrogative sentence. The second
part of the item consist
of OPTIONS or alternatives usually five or four in number where one
is the keyword or the answer and others are called
distractors. The examinee has to select the best choice. The test builder who prepares multiple choice item should take
care that no answer should be far-fetched or
partially wrong. There should be a gradation in the suitability or
correctness of the answers. While
seeing the distractors the examinee should feel the challenge to find out the correct answer. Response should
not overlap or be synonymous with one another. Do not include
distractors that do not fit in grammatically with the stem.
True- False Test
Items: In this form examinee will be given a
statement. The statement may be
either true or false. The student has to indicate whether it is true or false. In constructing such an item, the
setter should avoid sentences which are neither true nor false or which are intermediate. The greatest drawback
of this item is that the examinee makes guesses and even when one does not
posses’ knowledge of the subject matter.
The chances are 50:50 for a guess being correct. This item can be scored very easily and it can be constructed easily.
These items are useful for young children who
have poor vocabulary. It tests the ability to discriminate between
misconceptions and truth.
A large quantum of
subject matter can be covered within a short period.
Matching Type
Test Item: This is the modified version of
multiple-choice test item. In fact
matching type question comprises an economical form of combining a number of
multiple choice items in the same question. A set of such problems are
given against the answer with their
order shuffled will be given as answer set. Students has to find out correct answer
for each item. Question set is known as the premises and answer set is
known as responses. Several precautions have to be taken while writing a good
item of this type. The first point
is that item in column one should be homogeneous in nature. This will not only economies time but also help in
making the item clear and definite.
Completion Type
Test Item: The test item which requires the
examinee to fill the missing part of the sentence, a series or a graphic
pattern is called
completion type test
item. He has to supply the word or phrase omitted. While scoring such
test, the more important factor
tested being logical reasoning, there may be some differences in the correct
answer themselves. While preparing this type of test item avoid ambiguous sentences and do not omit too many words omit only key words or phrase rather than
minor details.
Advantages
•
It can be scored objectively and easily. The scoring will not vary from time to time and from examiner to examiner. Scoring can be done even mechanically.
•
An adequately representative sample of the topics can be covered. A
large amount of study material can be tested
in a short period of time.
•
It reduces the subjective element
of the examiner to the minimum.
•
It reduces the role of luck and cramming of expected questions. As a result there is greater reliability and
validity.
•
It promotes economy of time, for it takes less time to answer. It also saves a lot of time of the scorer.
•
It eliminates irrelevant factors such as speed of writing, fluency of expression, literary style, good handwriting, neatness, etc.
•
They have high diagnostic value.
•
They are free from the opportunities of irrelevant answers.
Limitations of Objective type tests
•
Items are difficult to construct. Preparing good items require talent, imagination and
effort.
•
There is a chance
for guess work in certain
types
•
Problem of cheating
•
Emphasis on testing the superficial knowledge
2. Short answer type tests
A question
requiring four value
points at the most may be defined
as a short answer question. The term value points indicate
a point to be given credit in the
expected answer. This diminishes subjectivity.
Short answer type questions are of great help in having a wide coverage
of content and each item can be set to test a definite
objective.
Advantages Short answer type tests
•
A relatively large portion of the content
can be covered in a test.
•
It is easy to construct, because it measures a relatively simple learning
outcome.
•
Questions of this form can be made highly thought provoking.
•
It provides little
opportunity for guessing
as the examinee is required
to supply scientific information
•
It can be made quite
objective by carefully
fixing up the value points.
•
It is useful in evaluating the ability to interpret diagrams, charts, graphs etc.
Limitations of Short answer type tests
•
More subjective than the objective type of items
•
Rote memory
is encouraged.
•
Mechanical scoring
is not possible because of the subjectivity involved.
As in the case of objective type items, due care has to be taken in preparing short answer type of test items. Properly
analyzing the content
in relation to the objectives and specific behaviors, designing problematic situations suitable for the evaluation of those specifications and wording the items precisely so as to
avoid ambiguity and subjectivity are the steps to be taken
for the preparation of good short-answer type of
items.
3. Essay type tests
This
is the age-old traditional type of questions, so well-known and so frequently used. It is a free response
test item and covers a large content.
This is the type which can
help in evaluating complex skills and other similar behavioral patterns.
Advantages of Essay type tests
•
It is the most popular form.
•
Easy to construct and administer.
•
Allows relative freedom of response to a given problem
•
Students can express their ideas clearly
•
It is quite useful in measuring certain
very important abilities
of the child.
•
They lead qualitative evaluation of pupil’s achievement.
•
It promotes originality and creative thinking.
•
Reduces the chance of on the spot copying.
•
The possibility of guess work can be eliminated.
•
Comprehension of the subject matter as a whole is encouraged.
Limitations of Essay type tests
•
Minimum validity. This means they do not bring out proper distinction
between bright, good and
poor students.
•
Do not possess sufficient reliability and objectivity
•
More stress
on rote memorisation
•
They cannot comprehensively cover the content.
•
Through essay type items, proper evaluation of specific
abilities of the students A
•
Since the number of items is limited, there is an element of chance.
This leads to selective study on the part of the students, which is not desirable.
However, the objectivity of essay type questions
also can be improved with proper care and scientific planning. The value points
involved should be determined as precisely as possible and the wordings
should be regulated as to reflect these value points specifically. Precise
scheme of valuation should be prepared and strictly followed at the time of valuation. These precautions will help in
improving the quality of essay-type items.
3.3. Student Self Evaluation- Preparation
of Tool
In education, the term assessment
refers to the wide variety of methods or tools that educators use to evaluate, measure, and document the academic
readiness, learning progress, skill
acquisition, or educational needs of students. There is a greater understanding of the importance of timely assessments for learning as well as regular assessments of learning.
The latest concept of assessment entails three dimensions:
✧ Assessment of learning
✧ Assessment for learning
✧ Assessment as learning
Three Dimensions of Assessment
Assessment of Learning
is the assessment that becomes public and results
in statements about how well students are learning. It
often contributes to pivotal decisions that will affect students’ futures. The emphasis shifts from
summative to formative assessment in Assessment
for Learning. Assessment for
Learning happens during the learning, often more than once, rather
than at the end. Students
understand exactly what they are to learn,
what is expected
of them and are given feedback and advice on how to improve their work.
Assessment as Learning is a process
apart from these concepts. Through this process students are able to learn about
themselves as learners
and become aware
of how they learn – become metacognitive learners (knowledge of one’s own thought processes). Students reflect
on their work on a regular basis,
usually through self and peer assessment and decide, what their next learning will be.
Assessment as learning helps students to take
more responsibility for their own learning and monitoring future
directions.
Student Self-Assessment
Student self-assessment occurs when learners
assess their own performance.
Student self-assessment is “the process by which the student gathers
information about and reflects on his or her own learning. It is the
student’s own assessment of personal progress in knowledge, skills, processes, or attitudes. Self-assessment
leads a student to a greater awareness
and understanding of himself or herself as a learner. Self-assessment is more accurately defined as a process by which
students (1) monitor and evaluate the quality of their thinking and behaviour when learning (2) identify strategies
that improve their understanding and
skills. That is, self-assessment occurs when students judge their own work to improve performance as they
identify discrepancies between current and desired performance. Self-assessment identifies further learning targets
and instructional strategies students can apply to improve achievement.
NEED OF SELF EVALUATION
Through self-assessment students
can identify their own skill gap, where their knowledge is weak see where to focus their attention in learning set realistic
goals revise their work track their
own progress. This process helps students stay involved and motivated and encourages self-reflection and
responsibility for their learning. Self-assessment shall be a regular
practice of every teaching learning
endeavor, because:
❖ Making judgements about the progress
of one's own learning, is integral to the learning process.
❖ Further learning
is only possible
after the recognition of what needs
to be learned.
❖ If a student can identify his/her
learning progress, this may motivate
further learning.
❖ Self-evaluation encourages reflection on one's
own learning.
❖ Self-assessment can promote learner
responsibility and independence.
How to
Implement Self -Assessment Practice?
Intensive conversations with students
need to occur before introducing any self-assessment practices. It is particularly important to
explore the assumptions and principles that underlie
the self-assessment innovation. The way in which self-assessment is implemented is critical to its acceptance by student. The implementation process needs to include:
✧ A clear rationale: what are the purposes of this particular activity?
✧ Explicit procedure: students need to know what is expected
of them.
✧ Reassurance
of a safe environment: in which they can be honest about their own performance without the fear that they will expose
information which can be used against them.
✧ Confidence
that other students will do likewise, and that cheating will be detected and discouraged.
Self -Assessment Tool
Checklists, rubrics and structures
for reflection are all tools that can help students with self-assessment. The most effective and common tool for self-assessment is rubrics.
RUBRIC
A
rubric is usually a one- or two-page document that lists criteria and describes varying levels of quality,
from excellent to poor, for a specific assignment. Although many teachers now use rubrics as scoring guides
to grade student work, at their best rubrics can serve dual purposes. They can teach, as well as evaluate. A good rubric
describes the kinds
of mistakes students tend to make, as well as the ways in which good
work shines. It gives students
valuable information about the task they are about to undertake and takes the guess-work out of understanding their
learning targets, or what counts as high quality work.
Preparation of A Rubric
Step1: Develop a checklist
and Rubric criteria from it: Checklists are the first step in developing a rubric. Teachers
can use benchmarks to discern
which parts of the task are
most important, and teachers can highlight these tasks in the checklist. The checklist becomes
the criteria used for the rubric.
Step2: Develop the point system
for each criterion: An even number
of points works
well because there is no
rubric middle or center point. In rubric grading, teachers sometimes have a tendency to choose the center point
value. If there is no center, teachers use the
descriptors more effectively and rely on the information stated for each
level of the criteria.
Step 3: Develop the descriptors for each level of quality: It is imperative
that descriptors be clear and precise
and that the vocabulary used be appropriate to the age level of students
who will be using or who will be evaluated
by, the rubric.
Descriptors should not overlap
levels but rather should act as a subsequent step for each level. Descriptors
often build on the previous level of
performance, and this helps students and evaluators easily determine
which level is an appropriate reflection of product
or performances.
Two major types of rubrics are there: Analytic Rubrics and
Holistic Rubrics. Here gives a description of construction of an analytic
rubric.
Self-Assessment
Tool
Name
of student: Standard:
Name
of School: Roll no.:
Sl. No
|
|
Completely |
Partially |
Need Improvement |
1 |
I
can explain the activities relating to commerce |
|
|
|
2 |
I
can describe the nature of business risks and their causes |
|
|
|
3 |
I
can understand the role of indigenous banking system in trade and commerce |
|
|
|
4 |
I
can analyse the basic factors to be considered while starting a business |
|
|
|
5 |
I
can explain the concept and objectives of business; |
|
|
|
6 |
I
can appreciate the development of trade and commerce in historical past |
|
|
|
8 |
I
can find out the importance of commerce |
|
|
|
9 |
I
can evaluate the merits of different types of industries. |
|
|
|
10 |
I
can analyse the nature of commerce. |
|
|
|
3.4. Teacher Evaluation: Criteria for Evaluating Teaching
Competence
The
greatest single factor impacting a student’s ability
to learn is the quality
of the teacher in the
classroom. Teachers are one of the most important contributing factors towards
the process of effective learning.
They are the primary source of instructions, information and data to the students. In any learning
system, syllabus and books are considered to be very vital for its effectiveness. However, without a competent
teacher, there would not be anyone to
guide and give direction to the students on how to comprehend these syllabus and books. So, it is essential for the
institutions to select and retain the best teachers for better output.
Teacher Evaluation
Evaluation is a process that
critically examines a program. It involves collecting and analyzing information about a program's activities,
characteristics and outcomes. Its purpose
is to make judgments about a program, to improve its effectiveness, and/or to inform
programming decisions. Teacher
evaluation is defined
as a systematic procedure for reviewing the performance of a teacher
in a classroom and analyzing
the review to provide constructive feedback for the
teacher's professional growth. The primary purpose of teacher evaluation is personal and professional growth that
leads to improved performance. It helps to identify strength
and weakness of a teacher. It improves student's achievement also.
Need of Teacher Evaluation
A
strong teacher evaluation system is central to improving teacher quality. It
provides the means
to recognize and reward great teachers so we can learn from and replicate their success.
It also helps to identify
those who need help so they can get the extra training
they need to be effective. The process of teacher evaluation also ensures that effective learning
is being imparted to the students. So, teacher evaluation is a very
advantageous procedure in educational institutions.
Criteria for Teacher Evaluation
Traditionally, teacher evaluation
systems relied heavily on classroom observations conducted by principals or other school administrators,
sometimes with the help of rubrics or
checklists. Samples of students' work, teachers' records and lesson plans, and
other relevant factors were also
often taken into account. While setting criteria for teacher evaluation, following points should be
remembered. Teacher evaluation should be based on professional teaching.
Evaluations should include multifaceted evidence of teacher practice,
student learning, and professional contributions. Evaluators should be knowledgeable about instruction and well
trained in the evaluation system.
Evaluation should be accompanied by useful feedback, and connected to
professional development. The
evaluation system should value and encourage teacher collaboration. Expert teachers should be part of the assistance
and review process. Panels of teachers
and administrators should oversee the evaluation process. There are no fixed criteria to evaluate teacher competency.
The criteria may vary according to the need and purpose of evaluation. But whatever may be the need some
criteria must be included like subject
competency of the teacher, presentation and management skills, use of
productive teaching techniques, promotion of teaching
quality and culture,
use of evaluation strategies etc. Here
are some criteria
that can be used to evaluate teacher
competencies.
1. Level of knowledge
• Deep understanding of the content
- important facts, concepts, principles etc.
• Clarity of thought.
• Understanding of educational theories
and developmental stages.
• Knowledge of various educational trends.
• Knowledge of pedagogical methods
and techniques.
2. Facilitation of learning
and development
• Transactional competencies.
• Use of appropriate teaching
learning strategies.
• Effective use of teaching
aids and devices.
• Ability to develop textual
and self-learning material.
• Implement the lesson plan effectively.
3. Executive and Management Skills
• Skill to achieve high quality educational objectives in minimum
time, energy and money through appropriate and effective use of
educational aids and active participation of
available human resources
• Ability to identify individual differences
• Establishes and maintain discipline
• Ability to diagnose learning
problems and provide
remedial measures
4. Evaluation Competencies
• Skill to prepare appropriate evaluation tool
• Ability to give appropriate feedback
• Ability to record student
progress
• Awareness of appropriate evaluation strategies
5. Positive Interrelations
• Ability to get cooperation from parents and colleagues
• Ability to keep relation
with community
• Social skill and social involvement
Module 4
Technological
Pedagogical Content Knowledge
Technological
Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) is a framework to understand and describe
the kinds of knowledge needed by a teacher for effective pedagogical practice
in a technology enhanced learning environment. The idea of pedagogical content
knowledge (PCK) was first described by Lee Shulman and TPACK builds on those
core ideas through the inclusion of technology. Prof. Punya Mishra and Prof.
Matthew J. Koehler both at Michigan State University, have done extensive work
in constructing TPACK framework. In this framework descriptions of PCK to
describe how teachers’ understanding of educational technologies and PCK
interact with one another to produce effective teaching with technology.
.
In the
above figure, there are three main components of teachers’ knowledge: content,
pedagogy, and technology. Equally important to the model are the interactions
between and among these bodies of knowledge, represented as PCK, TCK
(technological content knowledge), TPK (technological pedagogical knowledge),
and TPACK. The TPACK framework highlights complex relationships that exist
between content, pedagogy and technology knowledge areas and may be a useful
organizational structure to integrate technology effectively.
COMPONENTS OF TPACK
a. Content Knowledge
(CK)
Content
knowledge may be defined as “a thorough grounding in school/college level
subject matter” or “command of the subject” (American Council on Education, 1999).
It consists of knowledge of concepts, theories, and conceptual frameworks as
well as knowledge about accepted ways of developing knowledge. The content to
be covered in higher secondary school financial management is different from
the content to be covered in the graduate course on the same topic. Knowledge
of content is of critical importance for teachers. Knowledge and the nature of
inquiry differ greatly between fields, and teachers should understand the
deeper knowledge fundamentals of the disciplines in which they teach. In the
case of accounting, it would include knowledge of facts and theories,
approaches and practices, and real context-based applications.
b. Pedagogical Content
Knowledge (PCK)
Pedagogical
knowledge includes generic knowledge about learning styles of students,
teaching approaches, methods of assessment and knowledge of different theories
about learning. PCK covers the core business of teaching, learning, curriculum,
assessment and reporting, such as the conditions that promote learning and the
links among curriculum, assessment, and pedagogy. This knowledge imparts the
importance of forging connections among different content-based ideas,
students’ prior knowledge, alternative teaching strategies, and the flexibility
that comes from exploring alternative ways of looking at the same idea or
problem are all essential for effective teaching.
c. Technology
Knowledge (TK)
Technology
knowledge refers to an understanding of the way that technologies are used in a
specific content domain. For example, for commerce teachers, it is an
understanding of the range of technologies that a businessman uses in e -
commerce and on line business. Within the context of technology integration in
schools, it appears to most often refer to digital technologies such as
laptops, the Internet, and software applications. TK does however go beyond
digital literacy to having knowledge of how to change the purpose of existing
technologies (e.g. wikis) so that they can be used in a technology enhanced learning
environment.
d. Pedagogical
Content Knowledge (PCK)
Pedagogical
content knowledge is knowledge about how to combine pedagogy and content
effectively. This is knowledge about how to make a subject matter
understandable to learners. PCK includes knowledge of what makes a subject
difficult or easy to learn, as well as knowledge of common misconceptions and
likely preconceptions students bring with them to the classroom.
e. Technological
Content Knowledge (TCK)
Technological
content knowledge refers to knowledge about how technology may be used to
provide new ways of teaching content. For example, digital animation makes it
possible for students to develop advertisement copies of different products.
f. Technological
Pedagogical Knowledge (TPK)
TPK
denotes the ability to choose a technological tool based on its fitness for the
learning activity. Technological pedagogical knowledge refers to the
affordances and constraints of technology as an enabler of different teaching
approaches. For example, online collaboration tools may facilitate social
learning for geographically separated learners. \
g. Technological
Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPCK)
Technological
pedagogical content knowledge refers to the knowledge and understanding of the
interplay between CK, PK and TK when using technology for teaching and
learning. It includes an understanding of the complexity of relationships
between students, teachers, content, practices and technologies.
True
technology integration is understanding and negotiating the relationships
between Technology, Pedagogy and Content. Teachers need to know not only the
subject matter they teach, but also the manner in which the subject matter can
be changed with the application of technology that supports the learning
activities’ successful implementation. It is necessary to teach with technology
in contexts that recognize the connections between Technology, Pedagogy and
Content Knowledge.
4.2 Ways
and Means to link technology to Pedagogic Content Knowledge
Keeping technology as a separate knowledge set causes
problems, but when we understand the framework of TPACK, we can integrate
technology into the content and pedagogy of our classrooms. The integration
will help our students learn more effectively. Mishra and Koehler suggest that
TPACK should guide curriculum development and teacher education.
To apply TPACK to our classrooms now, Judith B. Harris
and Mark J. Hofer worked with colleagues from universities around the United
States to create Activity Types. Their article, “‘Grounded’ Technology
Integration: Instructional Planning Using Curriculum-Based Activity Type
Taxonomies,” explains how TPACK should
change the way we plan our daily lessons.
They describe a planning process where we first choose the learning outcomes that
we will be working on that day or during that class session. The learning
outcomes are the content. The second
step they propose is choosing an activity type. The activity type is the
pedagogy or how are the students going to learn the content. Finally, we can choose technologies that
will support the activity type and aid the students in learning.
The simplest idea at play in TPACK is that a person
who is a world-renowned expert in a subject might not be a great teacher
because they lack the pedagogical knowledge to make the subject accessible and
understandable. To be a great teacher, we have to combine our knowledge of the
subject with our knowledge of how to teach. With the increasing focus on
technology, we need to also learn how to combine technology with our content
and pedagogy to create an effective learning environment.
Linking technology is depend upon the techno pedagogic
content knowledge of the teacher, nature of the content, and the learning
environment. Now a day so many tools and techniques are available. Many free
softwares related to different subjects are available now. Teachers can use any
mode of technology like power point presentations, Prezi presentations, video
files, audio files, free Softwares like GeoGebra, Stellarium, Kalium, e-learning
materials like e-text book, e-journals, etc. which is appropriate to the
content learning objectives and group of students in front of him.
4.3.
TEACHER AS A TECHNO PEDAGOGUE
A Techno-
Pedagogue is a person who focuses on the uses of technology and whose
expertise is in electronic pedagogy methods and theory. A techno
pedagogue is not a systems administrator or a network administrator. The techno
pedagogue is a person who sits with your teachers and helps them see the
practical uses and appropriate uses of technology to attain their educational
goals. This person’s expertise is grounded in educational theory
curriculum development and course design. This person stays abreast of
new developments in technology and helps to fit new information to other
teachers in a manner that can be understood by the less techno savvy. The
techno pedagogue also designs, model courses that use technology for other
teachers to learn from. They exist in the training of new teachers and
help the programme make decisions regarding the acquisition and use of
technology in the organisation.
Techno pedagogy is a type of bilingualism one foot in human needs and
processes and the other in technology and all its potential. This is the hybrid
method of teaching in which ICT is being used for teaching learning situations.
Literally, 'pedagogy' refers to the art-science of teaching and 'techno' refers
to the art-skill in handcrafting. Here, 'techno' is a qualifier, it intersects
or crosses the meaning of 'pedagogy' with its own. Techno-pedagogy refers to
weaving the techniques of the craft of teaching into the learning environment
itself. A techno pedagogue can oversee the design, production and even
implementation of online environments, interfaces and tools that supports learning
on diverse processes. The techno pedagogue communicates and works easily
with information architects and programmers as well as professionals and
administrators translating from one to the other. Needs, assessment and
technical specifications are both part of the techno pedagogue daily work.
Techno pedagogy refers to the united potential of technology and to
transform individual and organizational practices. It is a rich and
nuanced conversation between the technological possibilities.
Teacher
as a Techno-pedagogue
Techno-pedagogical
skills are the ways to make accessible and affordable quality education to all.
Every teacher should know how to use technology, pedagogy and subject area
content effectively in their daily classroom teaching. It is clear that merely
introducing technology to the educational process is not enough. One must
ensure technological integration since technology by itself will not lead to
change. Rather, it is the way in which teachers integrate technology that has
the potential to bring change in the education process.
For
teachers to become fluent in the usage of educational technology means going
beyond mere competence with the latest tools to developing an understanding of
the complex web of relationships among users, technologies, practices, and
tools. Teachers must understand their role in technologically-oriented
classrooms. Knowledge about the technology is important in itself, but not as a
separate thing.
Today
the techno-pedagogical competency is very much needed for teachers in the
teaching and learning process, as it facilitates effective teaching and
learning. The techno-pedagogical competency is nothing but the ability of the
teachers to make use of technology effectively in teaching. The teachers
develop techno-pedagogical competencies then they may try to make use of this
often in teaching and it will in turn make the learning process simple and
effective.
In techno pedagogy, there are three areas of knowledge, namely: content,
pedagogy, and technology. Content
is the subject matter that is to be taught. Technology encompasses modern technologies such as computer,
Internet, digital video and commonplace technologies including overhead
projectors, blackboards, and books. Pedagogy
describes the collected practices, processes, strategies, procedures, and
methods of teaching and learning. It also includes knowledge about the aims of
instruction, assessment, and student learning.
The
aim of teacher education is to develop skills and appropriate knowledge among
teacher trainees for using and integrating the correct technology in an
appropriate manner. Every teacher should know how to use technology, pedagogy
and subject area content effectively in their daily classroom teaching.
Hence,
attitude and self-efficacy towards technology play an important role. Thus,
knowledge about technology is important in itself, but not as a separate and
unrelated body of knowledge divorced from the context of teaching--it is not
only about what technology can do, but perhaps what technology can do for them
as teachers.
MODULE 5
CONTENT ANALYSIS IN COMMERCE
1. Content Analysis
Content
is the subject matter of a lesson or a unit. Content serves as the basis for
the development of curricular experiences. There are two types of content: (i)
the processed content which includes text books, teacher talk, encyclopedia,
supplementary materials, work books, etc. and (ii) the unprocessed content
including artefacts, photographs, diaries, letters, etc. Effective learning can
be organized only by analyzing the content. Content analysis is the process
of breaking up the subject matter into terms, facts, concepts, principles,
rules, processes, etc. the scope being appropriate for the group concerned.
It has already been pointed out that content analysis is a very important step
in pedagogic analysis. For this the subject matter should be analyzed and
arranged in a logical sequence. This type of analysis is purely an intellectual
activity that depends on the cognitive insight of a teacher.
The
term content analysis has been defined by I.K. Davies as “the analysis of
topic or content to be taught into its constituents or elements and then
arranging them in a logical sequence”.
A
content should be broken down into its elements. Each element may then be transacted
by using specific tactics appropriate for realizing specific objectives. The
elements are to be arranged in a logical sequence so that proper cognitive
structuring Can be facilitated. The teacher has to employ his imagination,
creativity and insight in ultimately synthesizing the elements of the content,
to form part of the cognitive Structure of the learner.
Sources
of Content (knowledge) Analysis
The
teacher has to perform a number of tasks and use a number of sources to make a
thorough and comprehensive content analysis. Some of these are indicated below.
1. Analysis of the
prescribed curriculum
2. Thorough study of
prescribed text books
3. Analysis of the
needs of the learners concerned
4. Pre-determining
the objectives of instruction
5. Studying the
existing cognitive structure of the students concerned
6. Understanding the
characteristics of the developmental stages of the pupils concerned.
The entry behavior of students also is
determined to act as the basis for analyzing the content to be taught for a
given group. It should be based upon the needs and competencies of students to
whom the content is to be transacted. The same content can be taught at various
levels. The structure of the content for a particular group is determined by considering
the cognitive level of the members.
Principles
of Content Knowledge Analysis
1. Principle of inclusion: This principle states that, all the terms, facts,
concepts, etc. must be identified from the content. This will help a teacher to
have a thorough insight into the nature of the subject matter. While analyzing
the content the teacher should make sure that no items have been omitted.
2. Principle of summarization: With regard to this principle, the whole topic dealt
with is made brief and is presented as meaningful statements giving an overall
view of the topic. It is summarized in the form of major facts and other items
included in the topic for transaction.
3. Principle of objectivity: While stating the results of the content analysis
there should not be any scope for subjectivity that might mislead a teacher.
4. Principle of sequential arrangement: The content of any topic will have to be so
structured as to maintain certain logical sequencing. This orderly linkage
should be maintained while presenting the results of the content analysis so
that it will make the teaching that is to follow also logical.
5. Principle of clarity: This principle states that the teacher should
examine minutely the terms, facts, concepts, etc. of each topic and express
them lucidly. For example, while stating the concepts ‘Articles and Memorandum’
as a part of content analysis, the two distinct terms, namely, ‘Article of
Association’ and ‘Memorandum of Association’ should be specified to add clarity
to the concept.
How
to Analyse Content Knowledge?
For
analyzing the content in detail, first of all the teacher should go through the
content thoroughly. Here the teacher's task is to break the whole content into
elements and to categorize them into terms, facts, concepts, principles, rules,
processes, etc. All these elements
need not be present in all topics. Hence the teacher should include these
elements judiciously. A detailed discussion regarding the nature of the various
elements in content matter is given below.
1. Terms: A term is a new word having a specific
meaning approved in all discussions. The teacher should be able to identify it
specifically. For example, content of the topic ‘Levels of Management’ involves
the terms ‘Top Level Management’, ‘Middle pevel Management’ and ‘Supervisory
Level Management.’
2. Facts: The learning of any discipline requires
acquisition of knowledge of a number of facts. A fact is an event or a
phenomena that has occurred and agreed upon as something that exists. It is self-evident
also. For example, the content of the topic ‘Levels of Management’ consists of
the following facts.
1. There
is a graded arrangement of managerial hierarchy.
2. There
are three levels in the managerial hierarchy.
3. The
three levels includes Top level, Middle level, and Supervisory level.
4. Top
level consists of managers at the highest level in the managerial hierarchy.
5. Top
level includes board of directors, chief executives and the departmental heads.
6. The
activities of the top level centres round establishing overall, long-term goals
and ways of attaining these.
7. Top
level management is concerned with maintaining liaison with the outside world.
8. Top
level management is responsible for the general success or failure of the
organisation.
9. Middle
level management consists of departmental managers.
10. The
main function performed by the middle management is to act as a link between
top and supervisory level of management.
11.
Middle level management explains and interprets the policy decisions made at
the top level to the lower level.
12.
Middle level management co-ordinates the activities of various units and
divisions within the same department.
13.
Middle level management's task involve taking departmental decisions and
inspiring lower level managers towards better performance.
14. The
supervisory level of management consists of first line supervisors.
15.
Supervisory level are directly in touch with the workers.
16. There
is no manager below the supervisory level.
17. Supervisory
level managers are also responsible for planning day to day production within
the frame work provided by higher levels.
18. The
supervisory level management is directly concerned with the operative jobs and
management of workers.
3.
Concepts: A concept is a
generalised idea in the form of a mental image representing all members in a
set of objects or phenomena, that possess a set of essential attributes. It
forms a very significant component in content analysis. While teaching, the
teacher should give more emphasis to the concepts. In the language of any
scientific subject, concepts play the role of ‘vocabulary’ and hence they are
of utmost importance.
Concepts
can be classified into two types; (1) Major concepts, and (2) Minor concepts.
A major concept may include a number of minor concepts. While analysing
the content, the teacher should also be responsible to find out the major
concepts as well as minor concepts. For example, the above said concept
regarding "Levels of Management can be classified as follows:
Major concept: Levels
of management
Minor concepts: i. Top level management, ii. Middle level management iii.
Supervisory level management
This can be further clarified with another example. Consider the major
concept ‘Bank deposit accounts. This can be clarified only on the basis of
three minor concepts, namely, concept of a bank, concept of deposits, and
concept of bank accounts. The crucial point in any concept is the ‘essential
attributes’ by which all the items are classified under a set. Hence while
analysing a concept these have to be specified.
4.
Principles: A
principle is the meaningful linkage of two or more concepts given as a
statement. Example: ‘A subordinate should receive orders and be accountable to
one and only one superior’. (Principles of Management).
5. Rules: A rule is an established principle. While
analysing the content, the teacher should identify the rules in it. Example:
Rules for debit and credit. That is, ‘Debit the receiver and Credit the giver’
in case of real accounts.
It is evident that both principles and rules involve linkages of
concepts. Hence, these concepts form the pre-requisites for learning the
principle / rule. These could be specified while the content is analysed.
8.
Process: A process is a set
of sequential actions done in accordance with relevant principles, resulting in
a new product. Example: Communication process which results in communication
cycle. Here the principles and the skill for the actions are the prerequisites.
Hence these should be identified and recorded while analysing processes.
Advantages
of Content Analysis
1. Helps
the teacher to organise and systematise the teaching process.
2. Helps
the teacher to have a clear insight into the nature of the learning material
and its sequential order in the subject matter.
3. It
enables the teacher to identify the terms, facts, ideas and concepts that are
to be covered.
4. It
makes the teacher search for pre-requisites and ensure these before teaching
new items.
S. By
analysing the content thoroughly the probability of omission of any point is
ruled out.
6. The
goals to be set in the form of objectives, the types of learning experiences
required, etc. are determined by the nature of the learning material. If the
content is properly analysed and the type correctly identified it would suggest
the goals to be anticipated and the methods to be adopted for instruction.
No comments:
Post a Comment